CRCulver's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
122736390 | almost 3 years ago | Please do not add wild-camping spots to Openstreetmap. OSM only documents campsites that are in some way official. If you want to share wild-camping places, there are other places for that (e.g. the app iOverlander). |
89904888 | about 3 years ago | What is your source for all the tourism=camp_site nodes added around Lake Metsovo-Chrysovitsa-Grevenitso? (For example, 39.8320909, 21.1189556). I find it hard to believe that there are so many recognized campsites there. |
123620848 | about 3 years ago | I see that you edited this road: Is this cross-boarder road actually open to traffic? (And is it open to traffic from third-country citizens?) If not, the part of the road crossing over the board needs an access=private or access=permit tag. |
89099288 | about 3 years ago | Hi, I see that you have tagged a number of solar farms in Greece. However, you used the power=generator tag etc. According to the OSM wiki: osm.wiki/Tag:plant:source%3Dsolar#Enclosed_solar_power_plant that tagging is only appropriate when adding each individual panel inside the area. When you have drawn the entire area, the correct tagging is power=plant and plant:method/source tags. I have fixed some of these, but only the ones I have seen with my own eyes. |
111333242 | over 3 years ago | Is the intersection at 52.1126777, 23.1504025 correct? It looks very different in the Geoportal imagery. |
113323087 | over 3 years ago | Is there actually a sidewalk along the road at coordinates 51.9074006, 22.366938? Geoportal imagery does not show any sidewalk there. |
71025422 | over 3 years ago | You added surface=cobblestone to some combined footway/cycleway in Belchatów. Cobblestone is probably not the correct surface; such sidewalks in Poland are generally surface=paving_stones. Please check these ways. This is important for bicycle routing – routers may refuse to send cyclists down cobblestone ways because they are considered too rough and bumpy. |
54839182 | over 3 years ago | Could you please move the stop_position node at 51.5922990, 18.9605983 off the intersection of the one-way entrance/exit ways? Geoportal imagery clearly shows that the stop position is a few meters more to the east. I could do this myself, but I don't want to damage all of the bus-route relations in this town. |
92488843 | over 3 years ago | Yeah, very_bad is more of a tag used on roads which even normal cars would find risky or impassable. |
92488843 | over 3 years ago | That road looks perfectly manageable for bikes with robust wheels (the definition of smoothness=bad on the wiki). |
92488843 | over 3 years ago | You added smoothness=very_bad to some asphalt roads. This is almost never appropriate and it will break routing for trekking bikes. |
54360258 | over 3 years ago | Please do not add access=no tags to cycleways. This can completely break bicycle routing. If you wanted to specify that no motor vehicles are allowed, then the correct tag is motor_vehicle=no. However, that tag is generally regarded as redundant for highway=footway, highway=cycleway and highway=path. |
116560773 | over 3 years ago | The title of this changeset is wrong (carried over from a different changeset), sorry. The title should have been "Sidewalk-related tags and way tags from imagery" |
26200990 | over 3 years ago | You added tracktype=grade1 to various highway=track ways that you saw while cycling. As documented on the OSM Wiki, grade1 is only to be used for tracks that have a hard covering like asphalt. If the surface is ground or gravel, then the tracktype can only be tracktype=grade2 or below. Please correct this in cases where you remember the surface or it is visible from Mapillary. |
114217346 | over 3 years ago | You set Bydgoska street at 53.13721, 17.60213 to oneway=yes. Is this really accurate? Both Mapillary and aerial imagery show that traffic on this part of the road flows in both directions. |
116190011 | over 3 years ago | Previously, the parking ways under Wiadukt Solidarności were tagged as layer=-1, tunnel=yes. This is incorrect, as the Wiadukt Solidarności’s ways are already tagged layer=1, i.e. the parking and its service ways are actually layer=0. |
116187246 | over 3 years ago | This changeset involved changing the tag surface=concrete:blocks on a road to surface=paving_stones. surface=concrete:blocks is not documented on the OSM wiki. However, the wiki for paving_stones: osm.wiki/Tag:surface%3Dpaving_stones shows that this is the appropriate tag for the surface that is visible on Mapillary. |
115953526 | over 3 years ago | Why did you place a barrier=gate directly on the highway=secondary at coordinates 52.5328166, 17.5630722? |
115673944 | over 3 years ago | My mistake, fixed in #115769947. |
83082038 | over 3 years ago | What is your source for pedestrian crossings in Gniezno (e.g. 52.5363003, 17.6222129)? No crossings are visible in Geoport or Mapillary imagery. |