ElliottPlack's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
105384929 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105450012 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105450350 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105450380 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105450580 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105450746 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105453627 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105453662 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105453809 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
105455515 | about 4 years ago | You need to write longer changeset comments. Please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments What exactly was realigned and removed? |
97331413 | about 4 years ago | Here we go again with the massive cleanup! Why did you remove buildings that were recently constructed? |
104753007 | about 4 years ago | Some of the deletions here were for newly constructed roads. Did you check the history before relying on potentially dated imagery? |
104789797 | about 4 years ago | Perhaps you only meant to delete some buildings but it is clear in the dataset that the DWG posted in your block that the entire site was removed. Did you see that link? |
104688698 | about 4 years ago | Hey there! Nice work adding the construction values—I overlooked that. I wanted to point out that the access tags are not redundant for roads that are closed or under construction. The standard prefix for a “closed road” sets the access to no in order to supersede all other access values. You can see evidence of this in tag info where 21,000+ highway=construction also have access=no. I don’t think you’d want to go and remove all those tags. The thought, as I recall for GitHub, is that a closed road is not accessible, thus it is explicitly no access. https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=construction#combinations |
103137099 | about 4 years ago | Aloha! Thanks for adding the Hamilton neighborhood as a boundary. I updated the boundary a bit to fit the OSM standards and conventions osm.org/relation/12724042 . I'm glad you added this because I've been meaning to bring in all the city neighborhoods as admin boundaries, after discussing with some other local mappers. Is your motivation a running app like CityStrides? I like those and use a few of them. Thanks! |
104789797 | about 4 years ago | Additionally, it looks like the Harford Heights isn't totally removed but you've deleted the full thing. Part of this building contains address data. The address should be preserved when removing the building (but I wouldn't have removed the building here.) |
104789797 | about 4 years ago | Boop, please write more about why you're removing items when doing so. Your not writing good comments despite calls from the community to do so has caused you to be blocked, osm.org/user_blocks/5034 which is unfortunate. You seem to care about the OSM project, so please type out a sentence or two about your changes. I always try to answer What, Why, and How in mine, feel free to look at my edits as an example. In these edits, you deleted a bunch of buildings but didn't add any back. Are they under construction? if so, you should add a construction area to notify other mappers of the reason for the deletions. Then write a comment saying there is construction there. I would always try to trace the new building under construction and add the appropriate tags if you can. |
81304033 | about 4 years ago | Hi there. These roads are outdated due to construction in the area. Please note the landuse=construction and then be wary of adding roads that may have been removed within that construction area. |
103977292 | about 4 years ago | Since you seem to be interested in railroad edits, you may be interested to know that the still standing Ma & Pa abutments in Towson are historic designated. I've updated the tags and added the plaque on the west one. Here that is: osm.org/node/8731261473 |
97831409 | about 4 years ago | Hello there Amazon editor. The entrance road to that assisted living place is best tagged as service, rather than residential, because it is not a named street. Otherwise, keep up the good work. |