OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
48593865 over 8 years ago

No need to be sorry, thanks for contributing :).

The problem with having the English name in the "name" tag is that it is difficult to tell when someone removed the Thai name and added the English name instead, because they happen like the map better that way, or if it just doesn't have a Thai name yet. Unfortunately removal of the Thai names are not that uncommon.

Here is an example of that:
osm.org/node/3910735269

Whenever possible, people do try to add the Thai name to both name and name:th.

Some hotels/chains will have a Thai name in addition to their primary English name, those cases their Thai name is added to name:th.

48593865 over 8 years ago

Hi Mac,

I just noticed that you re-added the name tag on "Wat Chiang Rai".

The name tag is for the name used by the locals, for a temple that would almost always be the Thai name in local script.

name:en can be used for the transcribed or translated names.

I have been trying to clean this up for a while, and I can see you are undoing my changes.

For hotels, restaurants and other brand stores, it is not uncommon that the name tag contains the English name, as that is the name used by locals as well.

46653706 over 8 years ago

Dear HHC, there is no reason to name unnamed roads.

45915046 over 8 years ago

What is the source of this data?, the quality seems quite low and it looks like something from an automated process. I see lot's of buildings drawn where no buildings exists.

28502037 over 8 years ago

Hi Kyle,

Please don't replace the Thai names with English names.

Use name:en for English names.
The name tag is reserved for the local name which in Thailand is mostly Thai.

45389023 over 8 years ago

Here are a couple of examples:
osm.org/way/467919873
osm.org/way/467919857

45389023 over 8 years ago

I just noticed that you are still tagging residential roads as highway=service, please tag them as highway=residential.

osm.wiki/Tag:highway%3Dservice

44843403 over 8 years ago

Changing from highway=residential to highway=track should not be much easier than just adding surface=unpaved.

Also tracks are not necessarily unpaved. So your change didn't really improve the data either, it just kind of made it worse.

Anyway, you are not bothering me at all. I just find it better to address problems as quickly as possible, so we don't end up with thousands of similar errors in the map data because nobody reported the problem.

44843403 over 8 years ago

Hi Balthus, I can see that you have started to change residential roads to tracks. These roads are clearly residential, and probably unpaved residential roads. Tracks are mostly used for agricultural purposes.

41791704 almost 9 years ago

Hi Giulio,

The name tags in OSM are used in the following way:
"name" contains the name used by the locals, this usually means Thai name in Thai script. This is different for hotels and other brands where their primary name could be in English (e.g. 7-Eleven).
"name:en" contains the English version of the name, this is usually the transcribed name, though a translated name could work too.
"name:th" is the Thai name in Thai script (no English characters should be used here).

I am telling you this because I have seen you change correctly tagged nodes/ways and replacing it with incorrectly tagged data.

Please keep contributing, if you need help with the tagging, you can join us in the Thai forum here:
http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewforum.php?id=46

41626601 almost 9 years ago

Hi Federali,

When you mark roads as paved, you should only add the surface tag to the way, not each individual node.

Regarding the cleanup, I am not sure if there is an easy way in JOSM to remove the surface tag from the all nodes again.

43116656 almost 9 years ago

Hi Ahkom,

Can you confirm the location of this bicycle shop?, I am only asking because the location seems a bit odd and I want to make sure you didn't add it by accident.

39985555 almost 9 years ago

Please keep the name tag in the local language (in this case Thai).

39378286 almost 9 years ago

Hi kellerk,

Please use the name tag for actual names and not descriptions. Descriptions can be added in other ways.

26166466 almost 9 years ago

Hi Nilk,

Please don't remove the Thai names, name tags are supposed to be in the local language.

Use name:en for English or transcribed names.

41391223 almost 9 years ago

Please don't delete the Thai names from the name field. The name field should be in Thai. The field name:en can be used for English or transcribed named.

39898047 almost 9 years ago

In Thailand, the main name should be in Thai. Please don't change the names to the English names.

41594690 almost 9 years ago

Hi p0p9,

I noticed that you have added a lot of roads in this changeset, but they are all unconnected. Can you please have look at see if you can fix it?

Let me know if you need any help.

39412970 over 9 years ago

There is a bit more details on the "glitch" here:
http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=54635
We still don't know too much.

39365421 over 9 years ago

We are currently seeing a high amount of changesets from different users with similar changeset comments, some contain edits that are problematic. We would love to get your input in our forum so we can learn more about these edits.

http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=54648

I'd also recommend pausing your edits until we get it all sorted out.