"Checked around the block, no sign of it"
The place has gone or never existed. A user of Organic Maps application has reported that the POI was visible on the map (see snapshot date below), but was not found on the ground.
OSM snapshot date: 2025-02-27T10:33:49Z
POI name: Van Horne Bagel
POI types: cuisine-bagel amenity-fast_food
#organicmaps android

Cow brook

Church may not exist anymore

Here is a island. Water at the west side is missing.

Show also:
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:No_Man%27s_Island.jpg

StoryWorkz

Class 4 Road, Not maintained

via StreetComplete 54.1

"This is not open to the public (which you can verify here: https://cabotcreamery.com/pages/visit-us) and thus should probably not be in the category "cheese store.""
OSM snapshot date: 2022-12-16T15:17:23Z
POI name: Cabot Creamery Visitor's Center
POI types: building shop-cheese
#organicmaps

"This is a cafe: https://www.bentleysbakeryvt.com/"
OSM snapshot date: 2025-01-21T15:15:53Z
POI has no name
POI types: building
#organicmaps ios

Passumpsic Housing South

NFP Insurance
1229 Portland Street
St. Johnsbury, Vermont 05819
United States