OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
166681483 3 months ago

Welcome to OSM! Looks all good to me.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/166681483

166593656 3 months ago

Hello! Shouldn't the street address match the street name in OSM (Halsey-Sweet Home Highway in this case)?

165553173 4 months ago

Welcome back to OSM!

165546541 4 months ago

Thanks for catching and fixing these!

163869963 4 months ago

Carto wasn't rendering it before. It is now-I think what might have happened is when you split the way, the inner role for the relation was only transferred to one of the resulting ways. JOSM showed me a "unclosed MP" error. You're right, I should have let you know before fixing it. Sorry about that.

163869963 4 months ago

Hello! Looks to me like relation 18868946 broke here. I've fixed it.

165049659 4 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

164920557 4 months ago

Reverted

osm.org/changeset/164959980

164485137 5 months ago

Looks good. Welcome to OSM!

164444274 5 months ago

Welcome back to OSM!

164101185 5 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

163932247 5 months ago

Reverted

osm.org/changeset/163969778

163304341 6 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

162938397 6 months ago

Welcome to OSM!

162803161 6 months ago

Hello,
Please take another look at the data you've imported as well as the various wiki pages for the Canvec import. I see some issues right away:
1. You appear to be importing more than the approved data types (e.g. osm.org/relation/18736785 , osm.org/way/1361881766 , osm.org/way/1361881990)
2. Footways overlapping other highways. No highway=* objects from Canvec should be uploaded. (e.g. osm.org/way/1361881992 , osm.org/way/1361881766)
3. Overlapping water areas. (e.g. osm.org/way/1361881743 , osm.org/way/1361881859 , osm.org/way/1361881987)
4. Deprecated tagging leftover. (e.g. osm.org/way/1361881987 )
5. Duplicate place=*: osm.org/node/12609014267
6. Duplicate natural=water on nodes (e.g. osm.org/node/12608030522 , osm.org/node/12606175009)
7. Relation with only a source tag: osm.org/relation/18736805
8. Duplicate nodes (e.g. osm.org/node/2442258591 , osm.org/node/12608016044)

Most of the above are only examples of each issue (the first few I came across). There are likely more examples out there as well as more issues; I only looked at a few small areas which you imported.
Unfortunately, importing Canvec isn't quite as simple as just uploading the data to OSM. There's a lot of prep work, conflation, validation, and cleanup that has to go into it.

Happy Mapping,
jmarchon

162724573 6 months ago

Welcome to OSM and thanks for getting this updated!
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/162724573

140658074 6 months ago

Oh yeah, it's wonderful. I probably used it here too, going off the tag "source=Bing; DOGAMI Lidar" on the changeset. Thank you though :-)

162552550 6 months ago

Welcome to OSM and thanks for getting this restaurant added!

162315343 6 months ago

I think this is the train station here? osm.org/relation/10336724

162328159 6 months ago

Oops, thanks for catching my mistake!