syntex's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
93189350 | over 4 years ago | I think, that all of these empty azerbaijani villages should at least have a population=0 tag and maybe also locality tag instead of village |
93189350 | over 4 years ago | Btw I'm neither azerbaijani nor armenian so I think i have a neutral view on this conflict. The other issue is with the cities and villages with armenian population. But you can clearly see where they are if you look at the map of the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomus Oblast in the USSR. The territories of today Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh, that were not in this oblast, but are today occupied by Nagorno-Karabakh are just empty, as the azerbaijani residents fleed from there in the 90's, so there are hundreds of ghost villages there, staying empty for almost 30 years. This is clearly visible in the satelite images. |
93189350 | over 4 years ago | I agree, most of these villages are just ghost villages with no population since the Nagorno-Karabakh war ended in 1994. I think the practice should be, that they only have their azerbaijani name, especially for the ones that azerbaijan army had recently captured as no armenians live there nor anyone uses the armenian name for these villages. But you could have just moved it to the name:hy section for now. |
83403866 | over 4 years ago | Wikipedia also confirms that this village is in Azerbaijan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eyvazlı,_Qubadli
|
92982440 | almost 5 years ago | This edit is wrong, you can't edit political borders the way you want them to be. The road near Eyvazlu goes through the Azerbaijan territory and you just cant adjust the border as you wish !! |
92642423 | almost 5 years ago | Just to be clear, this was not an import, I added all of them manually. This PRG map is indeed public data, made by the government of San Marino, which can be found here https://www.gov.sm/dip/Ufficio-Tecnico-del-Catasto.html
|
92642423 | almost 5 years ago | And the source of the other hamlets, that I have added in the past is here https://mappeonline.pa.sm/maps/prgmobile/ |
92642423 | almost 5 years ago | https://ebikexperience.it/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Mappa-Sentieri-ebikexperience-Repubblica-di-San-Marino.pdf
|
92395689 | almost 5 years ago | Geoportal wskazuje, że ten adres to 9N. Ale to dziwne, bo tuż obok jest adres 10Ł, który faktycznie jest oficjalnie w bazach adresowych, także dziwne, że tutaj także nie wpisano 9Ł zamiast 9N. Kiedyś takie adresy mogły być nadawane, dopiero od kilku lat jest to już uregulowane. Może gmina dopiero po pewnym czasie go oficjalnie zmieniła? |
91733274 | almost 5 years ago | No tak, ale tu jest mowa jedynie o imporcie danych z EMUiA. Ale przecież prawnie te granice nie istnieją, to czego to ma być import? I jeśli oni je znają to dlaczego nikt poza nimi nie wie jakie są te granice? I dlaczego nikt nie ma do nich dostępu? |
91733274 | almost 5 years ago | masz link do tej dyskusji na forum? |
86242075 | almost 5 years ago | ok, nie jest, ale kiedy są już dodane granice miejscowości nie jest potrzebny |
91733274 | almost 5 years ago | Działając tą logiką, powinno się wszystkie takie granice z osm usunąć co dla mnie jest absurdalne. To w takim razie część może mieć dodane a reszta nie? |
91733274 | almost 5 years ago | Ale to w takim razie kto zna te mityczne "prawdziwe granice miejscowości" ? |
89106060 | almost 5 years ago | Unfortunately in this changeset you have broken the continuity of the woods relation (7388719). I fixed that, but next time please check the continuity of the relations you edit, especially if the relations are as huge as this one. |
12432027 | almost 5 years ago | Вы хорошо всё добавили, но я думаю что этот слой, который вы использовали был очень перемещавший |
90724888 | almost 5 years ago | Ale jednak to są takie działkowo-rolnicze budki praktycznie, ale ok, może być residential |
14951817 | almost 5 years ago | Ok, ale uważam że lepiej dodać to w formie note z opisem a nie doklejać do numeru adresowego bo potem tego nie widać. Te punkty stały 7 lat niezmienione z tym znakiem zapytania |
14951817 | almost 5 years ago | Jaki jest sens importu punktów adresowych z dodanymi znakami zapytania do adresu? |
86355754 | almost 5 years ago | Ok |