OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
52153207 over 6 years ago

A year later I mapped way 294789776 as a track (using GPS), literally meandering through the rice paddies. 3 years later, what made you change it to unclassified? As far as I can see it's still a track, giving farmers access to their paddies. This is bad.

52153207 over 6 years ago

In 2013 I drew way 220575744 as a track. You have changed that to unclassified. Seeing that it is quite long and possibly connects a few hamlets this may not be unreasonable, BUT this now implies paved. Looking at both Bing and DGS this is clearly single lane dirt. Can you please show me the image you used to make your decision?

55527822 over 6 years ago

Way 525942419: you connected this to the dirt road in the North. I can't see any connection here on any imagery, so I have removed it. The Northern portion of this is clearly dirt. (fixed)

52184823 over 6 years ago

Ways 525942409 & 525942546 are clearly dirt, at least the E section I looked at. (fixed)

55527822 over 6 years ago

Way 553800927 is unpaved. (fixed)

52047752 almost 7 years ago

Way 524733021: this is an unpaved driveway and you have drawn it right through a building. (corrected)

All your roads are offset 5-6m.

52049156 almost 7 years ago

Sorry, there has been a paste error, that way number is not one I commented on.

No, I'm not concerned whether a particular track is a road or not. Even on the ground I often can't tell and even my wife can't tell me whether a particular piece of concrete way in our village is a public road or a private driveway. What I am pointing out is a multitude of residential and unclassified roads that are implicitly paved, that are in reality mud and therefore stuffing up routing, or even just planning a trip. Adding surface=unpaved to all of them is a good idea and preferable over a mass-revert. There will not be too many that we need to fix manually after that.

52049156 almost 7 years ago

Ways 524747147, the N-S section of 524747105, 524747145, 524747244, 524747158, 524747157, 524747154, 524747153, 524747160, 524747130 are all dirt. There are probably many more, but for this one a mass-tagging as track is in order. This is what I mean when I say that the map is "polluted" with roads that are mostly farm tracks. You can forget about auto-routing in this area now.

55536234 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747198, 524747140 and the W half of 524747146 are dirt tracks.

52153690 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747106 is a dirt track.

52153690 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747170: the Eastern junction does not look at all like you have drawn it: https://i.postimg.cc/wBHxrBg6/image.png

Straight across the track and over the bridge, no dog leg.

52049156 almost 7 years ago

Ways 524747117 & 524747118 are both dirt tracks.

55536234 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747236: That's no way to connect a road! https://i.postimg.cc/KjD9cQCk/image.png

55536234 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747114 is dirt, clearly visible on Bing.

52049156 almost 7 years ago

Way 524747125 is clearly unpaved. This is what it looks like on the ground: https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/OwqAoRkXf0F_J2uKaHjR1Q

52159555 almost 7 years ago

Way 525735305: your original classification as track was correct. Pity you changed your mind. Also, all roads are offset by 5m. There are plenty of GPS tracks in this area to correct it with.

59187071 almost 7 years ago

Way 590239182: Bing images are 12 years old here, but it doesn't show a connection to สห.3064 and I think it's unlikely that there would be one, as that would make the jct. more dangerous.

62566357 almost 7 years ago

The northern part of way 625378452 looks unpaved to me. That would almost automatically all the side roads unpaved, too.

61509382 almost 7 years ago

Way 615565842: you were not entirely right in changing this road to unpaved: only 1 or two sections in the centre are dirt. In many places I can clearly see the centre line on asphalt surface.

61509231 almost 7 years ago

Way 615602462: unless your imagery shows otherwise (and it may well, if it is newer) the centre section of this road is unpaved.