OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

An open, cross cutting feature request for streetcomplete, everydoor, organicmaps and anyone else who targets mobile data capture.

  • Ask for location detection (yup), device activity sensors (maybe not already asked for)
  • If I am detected in the same place and that place has a shop=* or amenity=* for 5-15 minutes
  • Activity detected is “still” or similar (I put my phone down, or walked around a shop)
  • Can I please get a nuanced prompt at some point either then or within a few hours?
  • And limit current notifications to 1

Particularly for cafes, restaurants, pubs, etc.

Why: Google maps does this for reviews, to great effect. Ask me, while I am at a restaurant, with a physical menu “Is the cuisine vegetarian?” Or “what’s the website?” (Often printed on menus) Ask me, while I am a cafe, “is there outdoor seating?”

The problem this solves is often I don’t know when a favourite place is missing data. I go there all of the time, why wouldn’t it be mapped?

Give me a “no thanks” option so if I don’t want the intrusion I can opt out easily. But if I hit “yes please, nudge me”…

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Discussion

Comment from maxwellward on 23 May 2025 at 02:41

It’s funny you say this, since I’m actually working on an app to do this right now!

It’s still in its early stages and I have no estimated release time, but I’m trying to replicate the GM style of questions with an intuitive interface that can handle more complex questions to the degree OSM needs.

I’m also trying to do it with enough simplicity to be able to hand it to my mother and have her meaningfully and accurately contribute, while also having options for people who want to get advanced and dive more into the details of a place.

If you have any ideas, please share!

Log in to leave a comment