OpenStreetMap merkið OpenStreetMap

Redaction Sadness

Sett inn af Dion Dock 16. ágúst 2012 á English.

I noticed several of the highways around Crater Lake, Oregon had disappeared. osm.org/?lat=42.559&lon=-122.813&zoom=11&layers=M

A quick look at the history of remaining points (‘h’ with Potlatch 1, no idea if there’s an easy way to do this elsewhere) showed the licensing redaction bot removed them. So I added the highways back using the remaining points. That was slow going work and it really didn’t make me feel like I’d added much. At least I was able to add a few extra details along the way (bridges).

Which reminds me, JOSM has an annoying habit of suddenly not adding ways between new points; the most recent tested version seems to be the worst yet.

Anyway, the whole experience made me wish the redaction bot just went back to the original TIGER import.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Umræða

Athugasemd eftir Mele Sax-Barnett sett inn 16. ágúst 2012 kl. 17:18

That is sad!

I have that problem with JOSM sometimes as well, though only on my mac and never on the windows pc at work. Usually a reinstall/update to latest version clears up the problem for me for a while.

Athugasemd eftir compdude sett inn 16. ágúst 2012 kl. 21:44

The reason why even TIGER-imported ways were deleted is when a decliner split the way in half, thus creating a new way. So that new way gets deleted by the redaction bot.

Athugasemd eftir compdude sett inn 16. ágúst 2012 kl. 21:50

Noticed you missed a short section near Gold Hill, OR but I added that back. P2 will join independent nodes when you’re drawing a way. And you can also hit the “h” key in Potlatch 2 to view history.

Skrá inn til að bæta við athugasemd