DmitTrix's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
130615108 | 4 months ago | |
130615108 | 4 months ago | You mean this one? osm.org/way/1125471997 If so, no these are separated stones on a grassy surface, like said in the tag description in the wiki: "Commonly used for <…>, or areas to preserve the grass from being trampled" |
139446686 | about 1 year ago | Restored the "image" tag here:
No other items returned by your query contained "image" tag before. |
139446686 | about 1 year ago | @zstadler,
Is there any way to find all my edits where I deleted "image" tags? If not, I'm afraid I won't be able to find them all manually. |
139446686 | about 1 year ago | Regarding other elements: there should be a few (probably less than, say, 20) such elements; the problem is, I don't know how I can find them. The edits were done fairly long ago. ———————— Regarding multiple "wikimedia_commons" keys: osm.wiki/Key:wikimedia_commons says this: If more images are available, just add the "best" one or create a new Wikimedia Commons gallery Since "best" is subjective (which is actually mentioned as one of the drawbacks of using the "image" key), I'd prefer linking to a category or a gallery. This also covers the case that a "better" image is added there by a Commons user who is unaware of OSM. If there is more than one category that contains suitable images, the best option is probably to create a new category (if appropriate) or a gallery on Commons, and link to it. ———————— Keeping both "image" and "wikimedia_commons" keys: sounds to me like a fair solution for the time being. |
139446686 | about 1 year ago | Hi! First, my apologies if my edits broke things… Second, at the very beginning of osm.wiki/Key:image it says "the proposals for this tag were rejected due to several problems with the tag", and then lists a few issues which are fairly severe, to my opinion. On the other hand, using a pointer to a Commons gallery or category avoids most of these issues. So, I just followed with the approach that looked more correct to me. |
143600534 | almost 2 years ago | הי! תודה על ההתראה. |
129401904 | almost 2 years ago | Hi! No, it's not one-way – at least not in legal sense. I removed the tag. |
141969024 | almost 2 years ago | Hi! I added wikimedia_commons tag which points to a category (that I created) that contains all images of the place I could find on Commons. osm.wiki/Key:image#Unresolved issues points out a few issues with "image" tag, and I don't even know which software supports "image<something>" tags. So I assumed that with the addition of "wikimedia_commons" it would be better to remove all "image" tags. But I'm not that experienced at OSM; if it would be better to have both, please re-add the image(s) that you prefer. |
129401904 | over 2 years ago | (@hatul) Oh, sorry for that, and thanks for fixing! |
111051421 | over 3 years ago | Should be fixed now. Sorry, I haven't noticed I have incomplete edits when uploading this changeset. |