OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
62813175 almost 7 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!
You mapped a lot of sidewalks here as separate ways. Do you know the sidewalk tag which can be added to the major roads?
See osm.wiki/Key:sidewalk
I think you should use it here. Besides that you used highway=crossing +footway=sidewalk on some ways where
highway=footway + footway=crossing would be the correct tagging.
Hope this helps, happy mapping!

47503657 almost 7 years ago

Hi! I think the Constitution Trail should be changed to a route relation. Parts of it duplicate other ways mapped as footways.
I've contacted you because the initial mapper is no longer active. This change would require to split some sidewalk ways like osm.org/way/298683948
What do you think?

21370079 almost 7 years ago

Hi! Please check position / size of Milner Library. It seems the roof is much larger than the building itself?

50766165 almost 7 years ago

Ah, forgot to say that highway=crossing should not be used on ways, only on nodes. That was the reason why I looked at it in the first place.

50766165 almost 7 years ago

Hi! Please review osm.org/way/512161070
Both Bing and ESRI show a fence between the 1st and 2nd node, so it seems impossible to cross the roads there. I also don't think that you should copy data from a County Bike map, this is probably not a legal source.

29241572 almost 7 years ago

@AlaskaDave: Thanks for the info. I see that you started to edit this, so I will not do anything else here.

64027881 almost 7 years ago

Hi!
You removed most tags from the way describing the pipeline:
osm.org/way/253952219
osm.org/way/8987867

64014007 almost 7 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!
Please check:
You also modified the road so that the tags are now highway=crossing;tertiary
osm.org/way/109442133
To map a crossing you have to add a node on the highway, not next to it like here osm.org/node/6024983714
See also osm.wiki/Tag:highway%3Dcrossing

64014387 almost 7 years ago

Hi and welcome to OSM!
I've noticed this changeset because of the landuse=residential area which is also tagged with highway=crossing:
osm.org/way/418545628
Please be very careful with Go Map!, I see quite a lot of these errors produced with this app.
I also see many nodes with lamp_type=street lamp in this area. The usual tag for this is highway=street_lamp"

64028651 almost 7 years ago

Hi!
I've corrected the tags for some pedestrian crossings here:
osm.org/changeset/64034265
osm.org/changeset/64034307
I can't try it because I have no Iphone. Does Go Map! suggest to use highway=crossing on ways?
This would be an error in the app and you should report it.

55925902 almost 7 years ago

Hi!
Please check osm.org/way/548629361
You added highway=traffic_signals to a building, as well as a name. Was any of this intended?

63986164 almost 7 years ago

Hi! Why do you use the unusual tag highway=yes here?
osm.org/way/639137994
osm.org/way/639137995
I think unclassified or track are reasonable. If you are not sure, please use highway=road, not highway=yes

59089949 almost 7 years ago

I agree with mueschel. My understanding is that the routing apps should show something like "enter roundabout ... leave roundabout at 2nd exit". The apps don't need to know where the traffic signs are. I think when you map a traffic sign it shows that you visited the place, thus it somehow adds credibility to your edits.

63958192 almost 7 years ago

Moin!
Schau bitte noch mal auf osm.org/way/638812209
Das sieht für mich nicht so aus wie die Bilder zu highway=bus_guideway in wiki:
osm.wiki/Tag:highway=bus_guideway
Dort wird für normale Nur-Bus-Straßen
highway=service, access=no, bus=designated
vorgeschlagen.

29241572 almost 7 years ago

Regarding the position of the pipeline:
I assume that it always parallels the service road that is visible in the places that I mentioned?

63950537 almost 7 years ago

I am not a local, so I won't contribute to the discussion. What I see now after your recent changes looks good to me.

63959144 almost 7 years ago

Ah, OK, your cs comment said Esri World Imagery (Clarity) Beta, but you are right, Esri World Imagery shows the buildings with the current shapes.

59713046 almost 7 years ago

OK, I give up. You want to establish a new tag here and up to now it seems that I am the only one who doesn't like it. Since you added access=no at least it should not any harm.

59089949 almost 7 years ago

Ah, yes, it is OK to use junction=roundabout on a node for small roundabouts which are not mini-roundabouts.

59089949 almost 7 years ago

My understanding of the wiki
osm.wiki/Tag:junction%3Droundabout
is that the tag junction=roundabout should not be used on nodes at all.
Which routing apps do you mean?