OpenStreetMap
Deleting Unnamed Roads
Kejimkujik erabiltzaileak 12 Iraila 2009 datan argitaratua English hizkuntzanDoes anyone else think this should be done? I'm cleaning up the area that I live in and I see that someone has added some roadways that I personally think are useless. They are roadways that inside of townhouse complexes and don't even have names. Do you think they should stay or be removed. I've added the coords below. Again, these are roadways that go through townhouse complexes and have no name.
Eztabaida
amm erabiltzailearen iruzkina 12 Iraila 2009 21:15-eann
If those roads exist in reality they should not be deleted. Just because they are useless to you doesn't mean they are useless to others. We try and map the world as accurately as possible and with as much detail as possible, so if the roads exits, they should clearly be mapped. If you personally want to _add_ them is a different matter, and everyone should only add as much or as little as they like.
Kejimkujik erabiltzailearen iruzkina 12 Iraila 2009 21:17-eann
Okay, that's a good point and makes sense. I will use your advice and understand more now what needs to be added. In that case there is a lot missing. Thanks
42429 erabiltzailearen iruzkina 12 Iraila 2009 21:45-eann
If these roads are unnamed and less important, you should try to downgrade them as service roads.
marscot erabiltzailearen iruzkina 12 Iraila 2009 22:08-eann
keep them but yeah make service road, or maybe track and track_type=1 if you think thats better. the width tag also might be good to uses for future renders.
morb_au erabiltzailearen iruzkina 12 Iraila 2009 23:25-eann
Definitely leave them in. I might be trying to *find* a townhouse in one of those complexes one day...
JohnSmith erabiltzailearen iruzkina 13 Iraila 2009 03:27-eann
They would most likely be highway=service, but they are definitely not tracks.
amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️⚧️ erabiltzailearen iruzkina 14 Iraila 2009 21:57-eann
Definitly leave them in. Very little map data is 'useless'. Even having a map of all the postboxes is useful.
But definitly adjust the tagging. If the roads are tagged as something that they are not, then you should change them.
There is no community consensus on how to say that "this road really doesn't have a name". Have a look at osm.wiki/Proposed_features/Noname and pick something that you like.