I see many diaries on OSM, but unfortunately the good ones are hard to find, if they can be found at all.
In this diary, I offer some perspectives, without any technical pretensions, but just for the thinking of “what it might look like” in the vein of “Reimagining the OSM.org” or “Better-osm-org” but without the technical side.
This diary is a proposal, a reflection. Its aim is to offer a vision of what diaries might look like in the future.
Observation
Many diaries published by the community are interesting, not all of them are, but those that are would benefit from being discovered and promoted to a wider audience.
Diaries are not discoverable from osm.org. When a diary is discovered, it is almost exclusively through direct sharing via an OSM communication channel (forum, Telegram, Discord, etc.).
The aim is to offer ways to find interesting diaries more easily, to know which ones the community values or finds interesting.
Proposal
Categorise
Allowing diaries to be categorised offers several advantages:
- Easier to identify the topic(s) of a diary
- Have a list of diaries talking of a specific topic
- Easier to find a specific diary
A category would group together several diaries addressing the same theme.
This categorisation might be done in the form of keywords, for example: #tutorial #josm #streetcomplete #sotm #telecom #esri.
Add upvotes
To enable the community to highlight the diaries that have generated the most interest and that they found most useful, it would be possible to add a like (or a downvote or an emoji reaction) to a diary.
The same options for comments might be used to highlight the comments most appreciated by the community.
This system would be very similar to GitLab for issues, or Reddit for content.
Diaries search
Once the keyword categories are in place, followed by the community’s reactions to the diaries, it will be possible to explore the diaries according to different criteria: by category, by reactions, by comments, by creation date, or even by location.
Discussion
نظر از Negreheb در 1 ژوئیه 2025 ساعت 18:28
I think these are really good ideas and it might be worth to create a github issues with “new feature” or something. A more useful blog-site would be really cool - otherwise i thought how maybe the forum could be utilized as such - maybe with an extra category for example. But - that way some of the nice features that could be implemented would be gone.
Also, maybe Northcrab thought about the blog-section in his project? https://github.com/openstreetmap-ng/openstreetmap-ng
نظر از TrickyFoxy در 1 ژوئیه 2025 ساعت 21:08
Well, except through RSS (: I don’t remember how long ago I decided to add OSM diaries to my reader, but it seems that the only thing that annoys me is spam and diaries of users who haven’t made any edits.
I have no negativity towards newcomer-mappers, but I rarely see any questions about mapping. Most often some random text. It would be better to show them a link to the forum (challenge: try to find a link to the forum on osm.org)
Perhaps I wouldn’t mind sorting by the most commented diaries, but this is a slippery slope of social media algorithms
نظر از RobJN در 1 ژوئیه 2025 ساعت 23:28
You can see diaries at osm.org/diary/
No RSS needed (unless you want to)
نظر از nickjohnston در 2 ژوئیه 2025 ساعت 20:01
blogs.openstreetmap.org is useful. It includes all diary postings and several other OpenStreetMap-related blogs. It’s where I found this post.
Particularly interesting or noteworthy diary posts often end up on (WeeklyOSM)[https://weeklyosm.eu/].
نظر از Josuer در 9 ژوئیه 2025 ساعت 15:16
Hi Koreller,
I just read your diary entry from July 1st and I wanted to say I really appreciate your ideas. Your proposals for improving diary discoverability—especially categorization, upvotes, and the Explore/Share pages—are spot on.
I completely support this direction. It would make diaries much more accessible and valuable for the whole community.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Best,
Josuer