OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
70688662 about 6 years ago

Please don't delete objects en masse. Use JOSM's Replace Geometry to do this.

70680529 about 6 years ago

Please learn how to tag names,

70670861 about 6 years ago

"marked" crossings would be ambiguous as well here.

70670861 about 6 years ago

Ie `crossing:zebra=yes` means there is zebra marking here. This is to not confuse mappers with the tags.

70670861 about 6 years ago

(In Hong Kong `crossing=zebra` and the previous `crossing_ref=zebra` documents zebra crossings which has clear facility standards and pedestrian priority)

70670861 about 6 years ago

It is most likely an `uncontrolled` but with zebra markings.

70670861 about 6 years ago

Hi. `crossing_ref=zebra` is inappropriate here. I used `crossing:zebra` as the zebra stripe markings doesn't reflect its status as a zebra crossing.

70644727 about 6 years ago

@hd_scania He has a point on changing the guideline. That can be discussed further. For now I have already put a `motorroad=yes` and `motorroad:tunnel=yes` as a stopgap.

70644727 about 6 years ago

1. Hong Kong doesn't use "快速公路" this way. This is a wrong interpretation, based on your misuse of "高速公路" here. .
2. I do not consider Lung Cheung Road as an "expressway". There are direct bus stop access. It's merely a fully grade separated limited access trunk road, not fully controlled-access.

70645984 about 6 years ago

4. Stop ruining names. You aren't following the convention.

70645984 about 6 years ago

1. Please comment on other's changeset instead of treating your changeset as an annoucement everyone should read.
2. Hong Kong doesn't use "快速公路" this way. This is a wrong interpretation, based on your misuse of "高速公路" here. .
3. I do not consider Lung Cheung Road as an "expressway". There are direct bus stop access. It's merely a fully grade separated limited access road, not fully controlled-access.

70626397 about 6 years ago

To supplement, only CtB-NWFB omits that.

70626397 about 6 years ago

This is incorrect. The `bus_station`'s name includes "Bus Terminus", as there are also PTIs and bus interchanges in HK

70617011 about 6 years ago

5. With `trunk` it also failed to convey the motorway-like restrictions. At minimal `motorroad` is needed.

70614948 about 6 years ago

You need to add in `turn:lanes` and `change:lanes` for your deletion to function.

70617011 about 6 years ago

3. The extent of Tunnel Area is not known yet. It would more likely begin south of Ping Yeung Interchange. Unless the entire Highway is designated a Control Zone, it would not be meaningful to classified the full length into one type.
4. `trunk` is for roads belong to a Strategic Route. Unlike Tuen Mun -- Chap Lap Kok Link in Route 10, in the short term it is unlikely to be designated into any Route. `primary` would be misleading.

70617011 about 6 years ago

1. Please read osm.wiki/WikiProject_Hong_Kong/Transport/Road. In lieu of a better tag, it's opted for `motorway` for Tunnel Area. While I am going to propose a change related to `motorroad`, it's better to keep the status quo unchanged.
2. An unfinished road would of course not be gazetted yet, for that matter.

70464297 about 6 years ago

Please don't delete a way with 14 versions and recreate it next time.

70403793 about 6 years ago

>*Deprecated `construction=yes`

70403793 about 6 years ago

osm.org/changeset/70405586