OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
118056596 over 3 years ago

Please remember to move areas back to the original position after editing.

118076800 over 3 years ago

Don't pretend you are adding `official_name=`.

118076800 over 3 years ago

* Don't remove the short name.

118076293 over 3 years ago

N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate.

118076472 over 3 years ago

N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate.

118076544 over 3 years ago

This is not a printed map, or a `nautral=` feature. Don't put it towards the old coastline.

118076723 over 3 years ago

N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate.

118076800 over 3 years ago

Please don't add "new village" or similar if it is not used in the proper name. This is clearlyt defined in Hong Kong. Put it in `description:en=`, and use proper tags to express that it is moved.
N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate.

118076819 over 3 years ago

`place=suburb` is a "major area" "with a distinct and recognised local name and identity.", not what you think should be top-level.
N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong). Use descriptive changeset comments. Don't use changeset comments for expressing your opinion in a debate.

118076856 over 3 years ago

`place=suburb` is a "major area" "with a distinct and recognised local name and identity.", not what you think should be top-level.
N-th reminder: `name=` and `place=` the common name and concepts in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong).

118076958 over 3 years ago

`place=` should be put in the sociocultural center., not geographic center.

118076983 over 3 years ago

This is not a duplicate. Sha Tin Town Centre has various definitions, as small as the Town Hall area, as big as the entire surroundings.

118077165 over 3 years ago

N-th reminder: `name=` is the common name in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper. Put historic names in OpenHistoricalMap, not OSM. Discuss with the community, where the Discord server (https://discord.com/invite/CyG9zte) has been made available in OSM Community Index for a long time already, and there is a wiki project (osm.wiki/Hong_Kong).

118077219 over 3 years ago

Please don't add descriptor labels in `name=` as "development", "construction", etc.

118077078 over 3 years ago

Please don't add generic names or descriptor labels in `name=` (proper names only). Use `description:en=` + `description:zh=`.

118077152 over 3 years ago

1. Please don't add `highway=` directly.
2. `=motorway_junction` is for numbered exits on Strategic Route only.

118084910 over 3 years ago

osm.org/relation/13888157 is incorrect. This is already expressed by osm.org/relation/10460930 and osm.org/relation/10460929 !

118039739 over 3 years ago

2. Don't add irrelevant sources. This may infringe copyright. `source=` on objects is not preferred either.

118039739 over 3 years ago

Please don't add descriptor labels to `name=`, which is for proper names only. Don't add project names directly. Put them in `description:en=` + `description:zh=`.

118043218 over 3 years ago

1. For the n-th time: `name=` is the common name in public use, not what you think should be correct or proper.
2. Descriptive changeset comments please.