OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
145378548 over 1 year ago

You misunderstood the situation. The original park is of course by LCSD. That's not related to who the new part's underground or frontage belongs to.

145064541 over 1 year ago

Please don't include objects inside as `inner` . They are part of it.

145340935 over 1 year ago

Please notice that the 2 `inner` has been wrong included here. They should be excluded.

145355302 over 1 year ago

Please don't delete it directly, as it contains an address. Change it to a plain "point".

145290405 over 1 year ago

`access=military` is not standard. At least `private=military`

145302856 over 1 year ago

1. Please don't use `historic=castle` for non-"historic" features. This is fake and misleading.
2. `tourism=attraction` should not be used for individual `attraction=` inside a `=theme_park` . This is meaningless duplication and pollution.

144571241 over 1 year ago

This is a rock under the mountain Lion Rock. Local names won't be translated accurately.

143731237 over 1 year ago

I mean if you take it to the extreme, it won't be realistic to split it based on whether construction has started on each section either. The exact flow belongs to OpenHistoricalMap.
The project ceremony commenced at the end of last month. Temporary sites have already been handed over before. Contract signed with contractor this week.
Also remember OSM is not always updated frequently in applications.
Other `proposed:*=` features are much more loose. You won't put Route 11 and Tuen Mun Bypass in the same namespace as this.

145096221 over 1 year ago

Please don't remove addresses. They should be preserved somehow.

145079896 over 1 year ago

You can at least discuss why they should be deleted? Unneccessary doesn't mean not accepted.

145025517 over 1 year ago

Warning:
This guy (GSF1200S), knowing nothing about the difference between different users, accuses others of doing things they didn't do on random changesets of others.

145075035 over 1 year ago

Please notice that this is already added in `tunnel:name=` . `name=` is used for the common name. so I decided not to use this here, as it is a short and minor tunnel. For a different reason, Shing Mun Tunnels and Lion Rock Tunnel don't use the individual section and bore names.

145058249 over 1 year ago

My intention for the `name=` of `public_transport=stop_position` is to reflect the name in the direction, similar to `=stop` in other modes. So it should use "Central" , not the exact pier. That's reflected in the `=pier` , similar to `=platform` .

145024454 over 1 year ago

Please don't remove `highway=crossing` when the `=service` is not flat, and there are crossing facilities for it.

144964746 over 1 year ago

Please don't use `=wastewater_plant` for `=pumping_station` . That's for sewage treatment only.

144959895 over 1 year ago

Please don't detach `highway=pedestrian` from roads.

144955422 over 1 year ago

Please don't delete casually. You broke a `enforcement=traffic_signals` here.

144885229 over 1 year ago

Should it not be `building=service` ?

144608787 over 1 year ago

3. You have duplicated Nai Chung here. This has no effect.

144608787 over 1 year ago

1. `=isolated_dwelling` is only for a independent settlement (as in village) with 1 or 2 households. This meets neither criteria.
2. Again, the standard for housing estates in HK is to use `landuse=` . Please don't use `place=`.