Kovoschiz's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
150384745 | over 1 year ago | Please stop deleting and redrawing randomly. You are removing info as well. |
150326255 | over 1 year ago | Please don't delete `=footway` connected to a `=pedestrian` . They are needed to make crossing across it anywhere work. |
150338091 | over 1 year ago | Please don't add lot info as `landuse=` . This is not suitable. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | The other situation aside from concourses is when the domestic and international, or departures or arrivals (apparently the case in CDG T3) in 1 terminal.
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Another example of connector section having `=terminal` in CTS osm.org/way/1106836257
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | For named ones, eg Brussels certainly have `=terminal` as the 2 piers, but `=terminal` is also wrongly used on the connector section. Are there 1, 3, or 4 terminals? Worse there is a 5th osm.org/way/367788803 for the military part. Applications can't make use of such ill-defined data reliably. That's why expanding the use of `=terminal` is poorly conceived.
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | 1. The question is at the same time about why should overlapping `=terminal` inside another one be valid. This makes them redundant, and causes definition and consistency problems. Besides, how do you know why they exist as `=terminal` + `building=` ? Users may not know other solutions, they didn't touch the `building=` , or someone like you added the`terminal` back, etc. There are many possibilities. What I want to show there is as titled, and your point 2, about the possibility of `=terminal` `=multipolygon` without `building=` .
There are 5024 `wr[aeroway=terminal][!name];` results , that's more than half of the 9804 instances in total. Many could be valid as the unnamed only one in many small airports, but many more look invalid as being close to each other. It seems `=terminal` is not mostly used properly. |
150064118 | over 1 year ago | This is actually wrong. The absolute position is correct. It's the two relatively positioned on the west that are inaccurate in the first place. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Bucharest Henri Coanda, the `building=` vs `building:part=` problem osm.org/way/771096083 |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | `=terminal` without `building=` xamples:
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | 1. For "invalid", I used it to the clearly ill-defined `site=terminal` which has no indication on what "terminal" it is.
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Terminals vs concourses matters for presentation in application. A passenger going to an airport only needs to look at terminals first, then the concourses after entering. Making many `=terminal` inside the airport makes them less useful. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | A wiki definition isn't absolute, and it may be using common language, or describing common simple case of having 1 terminal and 1 concourse only. `building=` already means it is a "building". Repeating this definition in `=terminal` is redundant. The emphasis on "building" may also refer to how you shouldn't draw the `=terminal` to cover the apron, only the passenger facility. |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | 1. Why is it "invalid"? There's no "not accepted", especially for such a specialized topic. It is used by a few already. As asked there, JFK does have concourse A and B in Terminal 4. That remains unsolved.
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | T1 is one terminal. MFC and NSC are 2 concourses of it. This follows the name, obviously.
|
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Actually Ft Lauderdale, and Richmond. In any case, please follow osm.wiki/Good_practice#Don't_remove_tags_that_you_don't_understand |
149895936 | over 1 year ago | Please read osm.wiki/Talk:Aeroways#Aeroway=concourse . This is in use in JFK. This is not a `building:part=` . It's meaningless to use it without different `building:levels=` etc 3D attributes. |
149819829 | over 1 year ago | Please don't upload test edits to a live public database. This is considered vandalism. |
149808694 | over 1 year ago | Please don't change minibus stops to franchised bus stops. Create a new point. |
149772510 | over 1 year ago | Please don't remove the `landuse=highway` |