OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
162419502 6 months ago

Please don't casually change `place=` , as this is a controversial issue. This may be kept as `=locality` , as this refers to a very small reclaimed one to the west. It's dubious whether the Sky Pier Basin created by the artificial island should refer to that.

162286822 6 months ago

3. Please don't blindly merge different sections. They are split for different reasons.
4. The positive or negative sign of `incline=` has a meaning. It's interpreted in the direction of how the line is drawn.

162286822 6 months ago

2. Please split your uploads in different areas, and be more descriptive in the comments

162286822 6 months ago

Please read that percentages not ratios should be used in `incline=`

162249128 6 months ago

Have you actually checked whether it's an EVA? Because I have.

162248937 6 months ago

Please read that `=busway` is only used for phyiscally-separated high-standard busways in the likes of "BRT", not bus lanes which is here `oneway:bus:conditional=` + `bus:backward=`

162202075 6 months ago

Please don't directly delete them, as they contain addresses, and still represent a store space. This makes tracking and updating more difficult, wasting previous efforts. Change it to a plain "point", or "vacant shop".

162197211 6 months ago

`=permit` is defined as ordinary granted to everyone. `=private` should be used for "permit" meaning restricted.

162100739 6 months ago

`addr:place=` is used in villages for `addr:housenumber=` numbering each address directly, and matching a `place=` (there's none here) . `addr:place=` also doesn't work when there are housing estates inside villages. The emergent practice in HK is to use `addr:housename=` for estate names, and `addr:unit=` for individual tower units (think Tower 1A for a building split into 2, which fits the wiki description for different stairs) or houses.

162004648 6 months ago

2. Please don't delete the `=service` roads

162004648 6 months ago

Please don't delete the long-term permanent proposals. This is only temporary short-term.

162045603 6 months ago

Please don't delete other things when you aren't fixing it. Even it has been degraded, it shouldn't be deleted directly either.

161877207 6 months ago

The `highway=` and `place=` should be separated in this case. The `=fountain` is still part of the `=square` , only that it's no walkable.

161841536 6 months ago

`=ferry_terminal` is already added on the `=pier` area. This is the `=berth` as `=stop_position` , reflecting the name used on the ferry routes.

161816258 7 months ago

Please don't blindly accept editing suggestions. This `=light_rail` is a rubber-tyred people-mover, not the "Light Rail" found across the sea up north.

161805549 7 months ago

When there's no regular ferry service, don't use `=ferry_terminal`

161804985 7 months ago

Please be careful when dragging. The corner has been deleted here.

161440713 7 months ago

Cf "Yip On Factory Estate Site, Kowloon Bay" https://www.pland.gov.hk/pland_en/resources/approved_pb/hd_pb/index.html

161440713 7 months ago

Please don't add project titles as descriptor labels to `name=` , which is for proper names only. OSM is a digital geographic database, not a printed paper map. This topic was discussed recently, and the compromise is decided to be named as Abcville "Site".

161545141 7 months ago

Please don't delete the road. It will be reconstructed.