OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
162954690 5 months ago

Please read and respond to previous changesets. Don't create different accounts to dodge questions.

162945933 5 months ago

2. Please use OSMAnd to see rendering of `area:highway=`

162945933 5 months ago

Can you pleas don't use upload comment for discussions. No one is guaranteed to read and respond to it.
1. `=pedestrian` means pedestrianized roadway, physically capable of vehicular travel. It should be used for EVA, and park maintenance roads.
2. It's not deleted. `highway=` + `area=yes` should be used for large wide open "squares" capable of moving to every direction. `area:highway=` should be used for linear areas already described by other `highway=` lines well.

162907486 5 months ago

You changed some to `=motorway`

162782354 5 months ago

Please don't merge different `area:highway=` osm.wiki/Proposal:Street_area

162604029 6 months ago

This `building=` contains `building:part=`

162611659 6 months ago

You shouldn't delete them in the first place…

162611895 6 months ago

This causes a duplicate osm.org/node/2544686378 https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/railway-station-as-an-area/104839/

162606480 6 months ago

This was intentional. The `=station` only covers the station box with concourse and platforms. `building=train_station` for the entire structure. This affects rendering and routing.

162530344 6 months ago

It was dragged. Should be moved back to original position.

162541770 6 months ago

Please don't attach other areas to `highway=` lines. This is unrealistic, and makes editing difficult.

162337668 6 months ago

Can you please check it yourself after interpreting and making assumptions. Fish Wave is signposted on both ends of the outer section. The fishing platform is only one part of the area. Theme Area 3 is clearly shown to be an entire section between the toilet and Harbour North.

162337668 6 months ago

The `man_made=bridge` polygons were to be split across the `bridge=movable` . You should check the Fish Wave area extends westwards to the outside, and I believe the rings on the fencing are holder stands for fish rods.

162456568 6 months ago

This is for the `man_made=bridge` structure. It's not one whole continous walkable area either.

162442329 6 months ago

The problem is there's no "official" name for the north bridge, and the TD notice you might have checked used "Northern Bridge" to refer to it afterwards as well. `name=` is defined as commonly used by the public, or what's signposted.
I have already added `short_name:en=South Bridge` . That should be enough.

162422006 6 months ago

Southern Bridge is actually named https://www.td.gov.hk/en/traffic_notices/index_id_74356.html
Ref https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0IUhoYbsCY
https://www.landsd.gov.hk/doc/en/mapping/ehkg/individual_PDF/3_Index_Content.pdf#page=22 (don't use)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSl8h1nsTTE
You can see signs for TKO CBB. I forgot for Southern Bridge.

162422006 6 months ago

Please check that the Northern Bridge hasn't been named this. What you might have referred to is in lowercase "footbridge". This should not be interpreted as a proper name.

162419502 6 months ago

Please don't casually change `place=` , as this is a controversial issue. This may be kept as `=locality` , as this refers to a very small reclaimed one to the west. It's dubious whether the Sky Pier Basin created by the artificial island should refer to that.

162286822 6 months ago

3. Please don't blindly merge different sections. They are split for different reasons.
4. The positive or negative sign of `incline=` has a meaning. It's interpreted in the direction of how the line is drawn.

162286822 6 months ago

2. Please split your uploads in different areas, and be more descriptive in the comments