I wouldn't say this is "incorrect" so soon. If you look at the wiki description, "An exit from a motorway or other major road." and "along a highway with named or numbered junctions where a driver can legally exit" could be interpretated to this being technically valid. I see such usage in other countries, especially Japan.

osm.org/changeset/71640402

There's no need to delete this either. Please consult before you delete. I will revert this first.

Partial revert of osm.org/changeset/71005746 after agreeing discussion https://discordapp.com/channels/550009593468813312/550324691001147422/586589922228568084

Should we discuss this on Discord or here?

I can see why it may be confusing, but that's a persistent current issue pending discussion.
You can refer to a previous changeset of yours: osm.org/changeset/70182554

>It's is a `trunk_link` to Route 8.
* That isn't in Experessway area.

>Shun Long Road is does not have route number
Please observe carefully what the _link is supposed to refer to. It's is a `trunk_link` to Route 8.
>7 changed to Tseung Kwan O Road
Do you have gazette or any proof that it belongs to TKO Rd? Geoinfo Map says otherwise.

Oops spelling mistake, should be "HyD". It's the Highways Department.

I have reverted your two most recent changesets for the moment. Please try to explain yourself before making major changes.

What;s your problem?

It's a temproary stop-gap until we sort it out.
HK has a OSM Discord server. You can join if you are interested in editing here: https://discord.gg/ZdQzz7b

Sorry mueschel I missed your message.
In Hong Kong, there are major road tunnels and their highways designated as "Tunnel Area" with motorway-like restrictions. Currently those are classified as `motorway`. However, a mapper recently edited contrary to this convention. I have been wanting to change it, so I took the chance to apply a `motorroad:tunnel=yes` in addition to the `motorroad`

This is plain wrong. Please pay attention to the Tunnel Area limit of Lion Rock Tn Rd, and u-turn slip on Hung Mui Muk Rd. That should also be a `motorway_link` on your side.

They are still there, no?

What do you mean?

>* In Hong Kong official terminology, "快速公路" means "Expressway" designation
>* There's no "高速公路" nor "Freeway" designation here.

If you note the `motorroad` tags, you will see I have already adopted and tagged "expressway"s in HK.

>而以西九龍走廊作爲例子是因爲他與香園圍一樣是達到限速達到高速公路水平，但不是正式的高速公路。而在osm，他是並定性為快速公路，所以我認爲香園圍公路在此也是快速公路。
Look I get what you mean, but that's Taiwan usage. In Hong Kong official terminology, "快速公路" means "Expressway" (uppercase, proper term). There's no "高速公路" nor "freeway" here.

Thanks for the tip! I
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/70670861