OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
94947919 over 4 years ago

1. Changing `=stop_position` to `=platform` doesn't make sense. The former is located on the carriageway, the latter on the walkway.
2. Use `route_ref=`. `ref=` is for the bus stop itself.

94922536 over 4 years ago

`building=public` or similar is discouraged for their ambiguity. It could mean `ownership=`, or conflict with `building=office` for government offices. Personally I use `building=civic` for these, although this may similarly be questioned.

94911178 over 4 years ago

Don't be overly bothered by "dumb" validators complaining about no connections.

94911178 over 4 years ago

`bus=yes` is for the `public_transport=platform`. It's commonly thought `highway=footway` shouldn't used on `railway=platform` et al. Although, `highway=platform` isn't widely used locally, it should be considered.

94826089 over 4 years ago

It's preferable to use `was:name=`. `old_name=` implies TGT Hong Kong Data Centre 2 changed its name from Varitronix Limited, while it's actually repurposed.

94780978 over 4 years ago

Connecting them together degrades, rather than improve the data quality. Orthogonalize them and move them as needed instead.

94740151 over 4 years ago

On another side note, `description:en=` is always available.

94740151 over 4 years ago

On a minor note, abbreviations shouldn't be used in general..

94680152 over 4 years ago

osm.org/changeset/94740151

94670234 over 4 years ago

osm.org/changeset/94740151

94779491 over 4 years ago

Also, what's wrong with osm.org/way/796387354/ ?

94779491 over 4 years ago

Please don't remove `building=` when you add `amenity=parking`. I suppose it's also `parking=multi-storey`, not `parking=underground`. Functionally, the facilities above can get `layer=1` and appropriate `level=` (best to add the whole `building:levels=`); descriptively `location=rooftop` can be added.

94739952 over 4 years ago

osm.org/changeset/94740151

94740151 over 4 years ago

1. Please put the route to `route_ref=`, if you arent creating a `route=bus` relation yet.
2. Please don't put its heading in `name=`. This is for the bus stop's name, viz DB Plaza here. If the bus stops are coded in this bus terminus, that can be put into `loc_ref=`. I'm not sure if it's acceptable to put `to=` on a bus stop.

94527517 over 4 years ago

@sanctificatione Use JOSM's "upload selected" feature
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/94527517

94506362 almost 5 years ago

This is debatable. I use the criteria of common usage when deciding whether `name=` should be the structure name, or the street name.
At the very least, don't remove the street name.

94442485 almost 5 years ago

This is mainly not your fault. The iD editor software preset has to change the entire feature to a `barrier=wall`, removing other tags; plus adding `area=yes` for its object handling, meaning this is now one big block of wall. The most ideal method is to draw a new line along the perimeter for it to be the wall.

94421111 almost 5 years ago

It was seen as acceptable to add street info to sidewalks. Please message at Discord https://discord.gg/P8fxC98.

94416506 almost 5 years ago

Use `leisure=dog_park` directly, and don't use `name=` for generic descriptors.

94358720 almost 5 years ago

You would want to fix how this building is modeled before detailing it as so
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/94358720