OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
99896905 over 4 years ago

For Nominatim specifically, the problem is `=village` & `=hamlet` are ranked 18, while `=suburb` to `=quarter` & `=neighbourhood` are 20 to 22.

99896905 over 4 years ago

The other issue is often Sam Ka Tsuen is referred to as the representative village of Lei Yue Mun

99896905 over 4 years ago

Checking the history, now I see the issue here is that one was originally for the Lei Yue Mun Villages group, the other for the area. It's not straightfoward to characterize this relationship as to how a "village" (or `=hamlet`) should be modeled.

99867152 over 4 years ago

You can look at the surrounding objects as examples of what's already tagged.

99867152 over 4 years ago

(The other changeset)
In this changeset, using `addr:street=` may produce correct-looking result as `addr:place=`, but inconsistent and semantically off.

99867274 over 4 years ago

This is considered tagging for renderer. A building won't be called "Ko Tong". The correct tag to use is `addr:place:en=` for villages with address numbers assigned.

99867152 over 4 years ago

This is considered tagging for renderer. A building won't be called "Ko Tong". The correct tag to use is `addr:place:en=` for villages with address numbers assigned.

99847069 over 4 years ago

I suppose iD may not show `highway=footway` + `area=yes` clearly.

99847069 over 4 years ago

They were changed to a walking area already. I haven't had time to re-draw them yet.

99665737 over 4 years ago

Again, what's with the `=apartments` here?

99704560 over 4 years ago

Why the `=apartments`?

99779294 over 4 years ago

Ok I found it now. Please provide info in your changeset, and mention to the local community next time. There are some that should be `water=stream` (?), and some unclosed linear `waterway=`, among other issues.

99779294 over 4 years ago

Is there any good reason why you want do this? Any prior discussions on a worldwide attempt?

99682465 over 4 years ago

Mechanical edit question together with osm.org/changeset/99681526

99681526 over 4 years ago

Same at osm.org/changeset/99682465 with `=childcare` and `=kindergarten`

99666820 over 4 years ago

Please notice that there's already a `name:en=` entry here (don't know if StreetComplete detects it). It should be recorded in another field.

59645212 over 4 years ago

That's an old changeset. There's usually no `ref=` and `network=` for the smaller outlying island ferry service ("kaito" street crossings), both scheduled and on-demand ones.

99150493 over 4 years ago

Really? I know that `traffic_sign=variable_message` is used.

99578561 over 4 years ago

2. It's preferred not to attach unfinished roads for ease of changing

99571119 over 4 years ago

1. (actually a standard practice or convention, than preference)