OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
120028555 over 3 years ago

1.1 You shouldn't determine something out of reality based on directly copying other official maps. The `mountin_pass=` is already kept there, as it is a high point of the road (for the concept of trail intersection and rendering, `junction=yes` already reflects it) . No `=saddle` exist there. You put something on hillside.
1.2 My point is there are two concepts called Pak Kung Au, and there can be two label positions exclusively or inclusively for it even in official maps. The `mountain_pass=` is the high point of a trail. The `=saddle` is to the east, beyond the end of the branching road.

120023306 over 3 years ago

If the names wrong, please correct them only. Don't delete the thing that still exists in reality. Some are already corrected to `old_name=`. Please refresh your map cache, or ask your application to update the data.

120028555 over 3 years ago

2. I assumed the east label is describing the saddle (put besides for concern of label on printed maps). The west one is describing the actual mountain pass. I doubt the random FP marked on the government map means that label is referring to it.

120028555 over 3 years ago

2. south of where I put it, and the junction

120028555 over 3 years ago

1. `=saddle` is different from `mountain_pass=`. It is low point on a ridge for example, not the highest point of a road. Cha Liu Au doesn't exist as such anymore.
2. Even if you look at this official online map (which is a dubious practice), there are 2 Pak Kung Au labels. There are can be multiple roads passing a saddle, leading to muluple mountain passes. On HP1C, it marked north from the west label, ie where I put it; there is no east label

120009287 over 3 years ago

If the imagery is not enough, there is also GPS tracks supporting this.

120009792 over 3 years ago

That's not an English name either.

120000000 over 3 years ago

Congrats on changeset #120M

120009930 over 3 years ago

Please don't remove other names. Add yours to `alt_name=-`.

120009872 over 3 years ago

Please don't remove other names. Add yours to `alt_name=-`.

120009792 over 3 years ago

Please don't remove other names. Add yours separatedly.

120009624 over 3 years ago

Please don't delete and re-draw. You removed some info. Move it to the correct position.

120009467 over 3 years ago

Please move it to the correct position. Don't delete and re-draw.

120009372 over 3 years ago

Why do you keep deleting it?

120009723 over 3 years ago

This is already in `alt_name=`. Please don't remove other names.

119985036 over 3 years ago

7. The west and east part are opened in stages as well, so this is a never-ending hole to dive in.

119985036 over 3 years ago

6. Please don't duplicate the feature on the relation's members

119985036 over 3 years ago

5. It's `start_date=`, not `opening_date=`

119978508 over 3 years ago

This one has happened before, and is tricky. The reason for not using `=motorway` is this is not Tunnel Area, to conform to local culture, despite the norm elsewhere. Not using =`trunk` is because I don't want people changing them to `=motorway`, but still show this is restricted.
I would appreciate if you say something more useful than "minor change".

119985036 over 3 years ago

4. As I had told you, please don't use `highway=` + `construction=yes` in lieu of `highway=construction` + `construction=`.