OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
130229493 over 2 years ago

2. More critically, `destination:ref=` is used for the road route, not exit. `junction:ref=` is the correct one with unfortunate naming.

130229493 over 2 years ago

We have discussed this before. They now are function as the main line. If you do this, the westbound downstream of EHC exit has to be `=*_link`, and there is no logical point for the eastbound to become `=motorway`. See Tuen Mun -- Chek Lap Kok Tunnel Rd as a case for Route 10.

130211559 over 2 years ago

https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/access:roof#chronology is obviously added en masse.

130211559 over 2 years ago

This doesn't do any help. `*:roof=` is not an `access:*=` mode or condition. `access:roof=` was mass-added by an organized edit osm.wiki/HOT_-_PDC_InaWARE_Indonesia_Project_(Surabaya_&_Jakarta) which uses other questionable tags such as `building:roof=` and `building:wall=` which are flagged osm.wiki/Key:roof:material#Possible_tagging_mistakes or even deprecated osm.wiki/Key:building:roof in favor of the standard format`roof:*`=. There is a list of `building:roof:*=` https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=building:roof which should be transitioned out. I have nothing to do with them.
https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/building:roof#chronology has clear jumps. The 2nd most numerous https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/building:Aroof:shape#chronology was being eliminated from the peak near 100k.
Most importantly `access:roof=` is defined as "has an access to the roof " which probably means physical means of access for inspection and maintenance, not legal access by the public. Did you verify this?

130058247 over 2 years ago

For the n-th time, please fix your application. Not fiddle with data used by everyone else.

130018117 over 2 years ago

Ok nothing. Maybe that section can be treated as otherwise.

130018117 over 2 years ago

Airport Tunnel, Scenic Hill Tunnel, and Shing Mun Tunnels are the exceptions.

130018117 over 2 years ago

I use the same criteria for other major structures as `name=` should be the most common name. Viz Tuen Mun - Chek Lap Kok Tunnel Rd Tseung Kwan O Tunnel Rd, Tsing Long Hwy, Lantau Link, and Tsing Sha Hwy.

129969100 over 2 years ago

It's not open. Should be kept at `=construction`

129956433 over 2 years ago

Please refer to Tuen Mun -- Chek Lap Kok Tunnel. While Route 10 and main line with Tuen Mun Bypass is not opened yet, it is still a `=motorway` until the roundabout. (For it, even then there is an argument to remain due to the Tunnel Road being a fork connecting with the roundabout)

129962695 over 2 years ago

1. Please don't remove the connection of `=pedestrian`. It is the vehicular access for service.
2. If there is no physically raised island, `=mini_roundabout` should still apply to bikes. No need to draw a circle separately.

129603274 over 2 years ago

I can't reproduce it (by simulating a revert, then trying to re-do this)

129603274 over 2 years ago

That would be a software issue. This only splitted it. Or they were already broken beforehand?

129955379 over 2 years ago

2. Descriptive changeset comments please. This is not "minor".

129955379 over 2 years ago

Please check guidelines and the status quo. Only Tunnel Area will be `=motorway`

129952502 over 2 years ago

No it does not! It is not public.

129952251 over 2 years ago

Although it is Exit 2, it should be treated as `=motorway` main line. Otherwise, the main tunnel has to be `=motorway_link` as well.

129952332 over 2 years ago

Tunnel Area is at the eastern end of the interchange. It is possible have `noref=yes` `=motorway`.

129884134 over 2 years ago

No, please don't mark them as open until at least that day. This doesn't make sense for daily updates eg OSMAnd Live. For new developments, applications should be tracking as change. Another option is user setting constructed roads in routing.

129743353 over 2 years ago

No you should not use `=route_marker` when it is not such. This called lying to the map to make it show up. It can't show everything for everyone.
Eg https://gk.historic.place/historische_objekte/l/en/index.html#Anfang will show `man_made=survey_point` + `historic=yes`.