Logotip de l'OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

Diari de LeifRasmussen

Streets as Areas

Publicat per LeifRasmussen el 21 Setembre 2017 en English.

I recently added “area roads” to downtown Durham, NC. I made the surface of the roads visible on Openstreetmap. I was wondering if their is any specific way to map road areas. I currently map them as “area = highway” and “highway = service”. Feel free to check it out!

Downtown Durham osm.org/#map=19/35.99361/-78.89968

Downtown Chapel Hill osm.org/#map=19/35.91627/-79.05645

Chapel Hill Public Library osm.org/#map=19/35.93251/-79.03549

All three links lead to a place in Openstreetmap where I mapped roads as areas.

I anyone else mapped roads as areas, please reply a link to the location!

Ubicació: American Tobacco Historic District, 318, Downtown Durham, Durham, Durham County, North Carolina, 27701, United States
Icona de correu electrònic Icona de Bluesky Facebook Icon Icona de LinkedIn Icona de Mastodon Icona de Telegram Icona de X

Discussió

Comentari de Hjart el 21 Setembre 2017 a les 19.46

In Denmark (the country in north Europe) I know of one case of roads mapped as areas: The area around osm.org/way/441584563.

This doesn’t show on our standard layer, but imho has a number of advantages.

See more at osm.wiki/Proposed_features/area:highway

Comentari de Jual Knalpot el 21 Setembre 2017 a les 20.19

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa mantapppppppppppppp

Comentari de maxerickson el 21 Setembre 2017 a les 21.02

Something may have gone wrong, several streets are mapped as part of a highway=service area:

osm.org/relation/7546630#map=19/35.93045/-79.03707

Comentari de maxerickson el 21 Setembre 2017 a les 21.03

Oh I see, I didn’t read closely enough. I think if you are going to make areas, they should match the type of the road they cover, not just be universally service.

Comentari de Nakaner el 21 Setembre 2017 a les 21.30

Hi BjornRassmussen,

adding highway=service to an area a secondary roads runs through as you did two days ago is tagging for the renderer and discouraged. In addition, applications which do other things based on OSM data than rendering maps, will treat the outer ring of this polygon as a circular service road along the outer boundary of the road area! Please don’t do it. I therefore reverted this change.

If the road is highway=secondary, its area has to have area:highway=secondary. If the roads is highway=tertiary, its area has to have area:highway=tertiary.

Best regards

Michael

Inicia sessió per a fer un comentari