OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
166046667 2 months ago

Hey KindredCoda... Thanks for adding the GGB building structure! I'm wondering if a type=building relation would be better here. Then all the parts would be role=part. See osm.wiki/Relation:building
The way it is now as a multipolygon and all the parts that overlap each other as role=outer doesn't really work very well because "Generally, the multipolygon relation can be used to build multipolygons in compliance with the OGC Simple Feature standard (Graphical examples of OGC validity). Anything that is not a valid multipolygon according to this standard (e.g., polygons with intersecting rings) should also be considered an invalid multipolygon relation, with the notable exception of touching inner rings (see below)."

Just a thought - I don't think it would be hard to convert it - you've done all the hard work already.

165720041 3 months ago

This caused many duplicate houses. Please verify that your conflation process does not lead to duplicate buildings.

164793632 3 months ago

Hello CAT Fijn, please don't add the address of a house to the name. residential houses generally don't have names. add an address if you would like to. Also, please don't add buildings on top of other buildings.

164705338 3 months ago

adi04, you seem to be duplicating buildings that are already on the map. I see you are relatively new, so this is probably a mistake. I'm deleting the duplicates... but please review the wiki about adding buildings to the map. No need to duplicate geometries.

165574561 3 months ago

This is obvious fantasy and not based on reality. Please revert this changeset.

161595350 3 months ago

Why did you make buildings into diamond shapes? See w531354067

163908418 3 months ago

It looks like this edit broke r13737951. Can you please take a look and see if you can fix it? I'm seeing that this multipolygon has an unclosed part.

165378833 3 months ago

Just wondering... are the "names" that you are assigning actually addresses? Or are they actually the name of the buildings? Just wondering if these should actually be address = <blah> ?

163717125 4 months ago

Botirjon2020 - these are not houses. These appear to be "place=plot". Please correct them. Building=* is meant to trace the outline of a structure - not a plot boundary.

163805085 4 months ago

Hello Botirjon2020. I wanted to just point out that "buildings" are meant to trace the outline of a building. They are not meant as property boundaries. It looks like you are drawing property boundaries. I think you want to you place=plot (osm.wiki/Tag:place%3Dplot) instead of building=yes

Привет, Botirjon2020. Я просто хотел отметить, что "buildings" предназначены для обозначения контура здания. Они не предназначены для обозначения границ собственности. Похоже, вы рисуете границы собственности. Я думаю, вы хотите использовать "place=plot" (osm.wiki/Tag:place%3Dplot) вместо "building=yes"

164270861 4 months ago

Ooops. meant to say that I removed a bunch of duplicate nodes.

146418631 4 months ago

Sorry, my fault. The initial issue was that the two ways intersected without a shared node. I incorrectly made other changes - my apologies.

163261711 4 months ago

It had a self intersection. So I converted it to a relation with two members. One for outer and one for inner.

159560286 7 months ago

It looks like the Changeset duplicated many of the buildings created in changeset 159543060. Can you please revert these duplicate buildings? Also, I'm wondering how this happened as you are using Rapid and Rapid should show you where buildings have already been mapped.