OpenStreetMapi logo OpenStreetMap

Kasutaja PlaneMad päevik

Data disaster: Nukus, Uzbekistan

Postitas PlaneMad kuupäeval 9. september 2015 – English.

While inspecting routing errors using the OSM Inspector unconnected issues, stumbled on this town called Nukus which seemed to have some duplicated data.

screenshot 2015-09-09 10 53 44

JOSM Validator report for the area:

  • Errors 6432
  • Duplicated ways 1355
  • Duplicated nodes 5059
  • Duplicated relations 14
  • Warnings 10299
  • Crossing ways 5748
  • Way end near highway 524
  • Overlapping highways 265
  • Duplicated nodes 192

The changeset which caused this seems to be the case of a large upload gone wrong. Wondering if JOSM should have never allowed such a massive upload without splitting it into chunks.

What a disaster.

Asukoht: №51 Ǵarezsizlik MPJ, Nukus, Nókis qalası hákimiyatı, Republic of Karakalpakstan, Uzbekistan
E-kirja ikoon Bluesky ikoon Facebooki ikoon LinkedIni ikoon Mastodoni ikoon Telegrami ikoon X-i ikoon

Arutelu

Kommentaar kasutajalt michaelsirianniz 11. september 2015, kell 09:50

haha, love the .gif !

Kommentaar kasutajalt Warin61 11. september 2015, kell 10:35

Oh… errr … well it was not me. :)

Perhaps the easiest solution is a revert. Good Luck.

Kommentaar kasutajalt Marych_ 22. september 2015, kell 05:26

I’ve tired to revert - unsuccessful, got reverter conflicts ( links to the deleted relation) stephan75 wrote an email to the osm.wiki/Data_working_group

Still no changes.

kommenteerimiseks logi sisse