OpenStreetMapi logo OpenStreetMap

The problem

A new user accidently added addr:city and addr:province tags to a large selection of objects, including rivers and individual nodes.

screenshot 2016-06-24 13 58 54
Changeset | Diff

The user mentioned that the tags were intended only for buildings, so thought I would document the cleanup for future efforts like this.

Finding all the problematic data using Overpass

It is possible to extract all objects with addr:city added by the particular user using this Overpass query.

screenshot 2016-06-24 14 05 28
Resulting features

This data can be exported into JOSM via remote control for further inspection and cleanup.

Fixing data in JOSM

Once all the data is loaded, we need to select only those objects or features that have been incorrectly tagged with the addr:city and addr:province. Since we know that the tags are valid on building ways, we will use a filter to select such tags on anything that is not a building way. We can use the find dialog (ctrl+F or cmd+F) to look for exactly this.

screenshot 2016-06-24 14 14 24
Find all objects tagged with addr:city and not a building

This selected 3,989 objects from which the tag can be deleted. Just select and delete the tags.

As a bonus got to also cleanup duplicate nodes using the validator. screenshot 2016-06-24 14 20 12

Upload with a descriptive changeset comment and all done!

Asukoht: Kaunlaran 2 Village, Molino, Bacoor, Cavite, Calabarzon, 4102, Philippines
E-kirja ikoon Bluesky ikoon Facebooki ikoon LinkedIni ikoon Mastodoni ikoon Telegrami ikoon X-i ikoon

Arutelu

Kommentaar kasutajalt Zverik 24. juuni 2016, kell 11:07

Actually, addr:city tag can be found on address points: nodes without any tags besides addr:*. These are pretty common in Europe and a lot of other countries where detailed imagery for tracing building is not available.

Kommentaar kasutajalt manings 24. juuni 2016, kell 12:50

This is obviously wrong in the Philippines. Thanks for fixing @planemad!

Kommentaar kasutajalt jssulapas 26. juuni 2016, kell 07:45

This is very helpful. Thanks for saving me!

kommenteerimiseks logi sisse