Lògo d'OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

Comparing GIS and OpenStreetMap data

Postat per PlaneMad a 1 de junh 2017 en English

Usually when meeting old timer GIS users in academia or government, there are a bunch of questions I get asked about how OSM data fits into the more traditional GIS model where data is organised into shapefiles and layers.

Since I could not really find a simple article which explained the difference, spent a few minutes today to come up with a (possibly) easy to understand benefits table for someone in Government. Its not technically accurate, but could quickly help pitch the idea for opening up more data.

Its still very rough, feel free to contribute any suggestions/improvements that could make this useful.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Discussion

Comentari de giggls lo 1 de junh 2017 a 16:05

Shape is a crappy ancient format from DOS days

A more modern Version would be something like spatialite.

Howevver the main difference between osm format and shape format is that osm format does contain a topology.

Comentari de Zverik lo 1 de junh 2017 a 16:25

“Easy to process: yes / wtf how do I untagle topologies help”

Comentari de naveenpf lo 2 de junh 2017 a 03:33

good writeup.. we should document this in osm wiki

Comentari de amapanda ᚛ᚐᚋᚐᚅᚇᚐ᚜ 🏳️‍⚧️ lo 2 de junh 2017 a 13:50

I’m wary of promoting “free cloud hosting of data”, since OSM doesn’t allow you to put anything you want in there. It’s one global database, and if you put your custom data into it, people can (and probably will) just delete. OSM Isn’t just a data storage service.

Connectatz-vos per ajustar un comentari