OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
41082188 over 8 years ago

Hi gaz3434, you have accidentially added building=yes and amenity=place_of_worship to the whole church ground. That should be used on the church itself, only (way 434336493).
I have meanwhile refined the grounds and drew the church building. You can use landuse=religious for the grounds.

46496897 over 8 years ago

Full revert in CS 46692924 for incorrectly separating roads+waterways serving as border member; restoring useful additions in 46693197, refinements in 46693752.

46659194 over 8 years ago

Victor, when reverting CS 46496897 with the boundary splitting, I had to include your CS here in the revert.
I attempted to restore useful stuff from both CSs, you might doublecheck.
It would be a good idea to do repairs and own additions in separate CSs, though.

46492533 over 8 years ago

I was in PM discussions with the user, as this has been commented in other similar cases as well. I think this is understood now, and I am repairing these issues backwards over the next few days.

46496897 over 8 years ago

@VictorIE: those will be fixed automatically when I revert the incorrect boundary line separations.

46497396 over 8 years ago

full revert in CS 46689935, see explanation there

46498237 over 8 years ago

full revert in CS 46689935, see explanation there

46497298 over 8 years ago

fine

46517951 over 8 years ago

Selective revert of the separation of waterways from border lines (CS 46688164).
The roundabout w204728237 was not visible neither in bing nor Bing, exceptional source:geometry set according to previous changeset comments and GPS evidence (CS 46688307).
Selective revert of the separation of Coa Road from border lines, which caused cycle routes going over border lines instead of roads (CS 46688805).

41264608 over 8 years ago

Fully agree with hsimpson and kreuzschnabel on my practical experience using OsmAnd, and find the calculation by 'its so funny' rather theoretical.
The satnav device is just part of the information I process as a driver.

46080700 over 8 years ago

Hallo webpassenger, sehr nett. Allerdings stehen einige der Eimer auf der Strasse. Kannst du in deinem JOSM den DOP2016-Layer aus dem Geoportal einbinden, und mit deinen GPS-Daten vergleichen? osm.wiki/Geoportal_Berlin

46519440 over 8 years ago

This CS deleted school w255709094, just to redraw the nearly identical campus in w478058571. Same with boat house w255709093 and w478058570. Original versions restored in CS 46654702. School campus is sharing the river boundary, that is fine. Boathouse was sharing a node, fixed.
A river defining a border was drawn in parallel. New way removed and tagging restored in CS 46654924.
For resolving a forest multipolygon into a simple, two original outer members were deleted, instead of using the larger one to extend it to the full outline. Not restored.

46526305 over 8 years ago

Fivemiletown edits 46526305+46525145+46523754 reverted in 46637434 and selectively restored in CS 46637891, 46639210, 46639252, 46639371, 46639474

46523754 over 8 years ago

Fivemiletown edits 46526305+46525145+46523754 reverted in 46637434 and selectively restored in CS 46637891, 46639210, 46639252, 46639371, 46639474

46525145 over 8 years ago

Fivemiletown edits 46526305+46525145+46523754 reverted in 46637434 and selectively restored in CS 46637891, 46639210, 46639252, 46639371, 46639474

41264608 over 8 years ago

Haven't checked the node (which?) yet, however I'd also prefer to have the split at the physical separation and not the legal separation.
As the wiki talk page shows, that seems to be controversial, though.

46487909 over 8 years ago

On osm.org/way/310656818 you removed the 'wall' tag a local mapper had used. bing clearly shows a structure here, and dry stone walls are quite typical in Ireland.

46461103 over 8 years ago

I was wondering how you knew from Bing that the church osm.org/way/477636053 was roman-catholic. In Achavi it became apparent that the information was from deleted node osm.org/node/802007097
It would be good practice to keep such node alive, e.g. to use it as a corner of the building, or the entrance if known, without tags of course, to preserve the history of the information.
Thanks

46445512 over 8 years ago

Thanks, plausible additions.
Please use "service=driveway" for private driveways.
Please use a general source tag like Bing on the changeset, not on each object.

46445202 over 8 years ago

This CS apparently creates a large number of disconnected nodes, deletes them in the same changeset, and creates them again.
The CS comment is incorrect, this does not add any farmland or buildings, and does not fix any errors.
Full revert (delete remaining 149 disconnected nodes) in CS 46608967.