SafwatHalaby's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
53235866 | almost 8 years ago | Was the Wikidata removal on purpose? https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q2521591 |
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | Thank you for the thorough comment. You changed my mind. I now agree that the attorney example is too self-promoting and could have been 3-4 words, and that its word redundancy is spammy. |
53226639 | almost 8 years ago | Hello, welcome to OSM.
|
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | I agree to that line. (And I'd suggest leaving the description too if it's factual and not spammy).
|
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | It seems the majority of this changeset is real, clear cut spam, though. |
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | Just another comparison to draw a clear line between spam and self-interest driven neutral edits:
|
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | For comparison, this is something I would flag as spam for the excessive ad tone, and I would justify its removal: osm.org/node/5135107648/history |
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | Although the intentions are clearly good, in my humble opinion this is harming the map and must be discussed. |
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | That was one example, but a significant number of your reverts do not remotely qualify as spam, and I think no one would have had any problem if an experienced mapper had added them. |
53216381 | almost 8 years ago | Hi woodpeck. I think your definition of spam is too broad. For instance, this random POI: osm.org/node/4923689269
|
53205305 | almost 8 years ago | How come it's a cycleway with no cycle access allowed?? |
53136409 | almost 8 years ago | Welcome to Openstreetmap!
|
53114647 | almost 8 years ago | Oh, I was reviewing via OSMCHA and I have a long backlog, and it seems that particular node was added back. Please ignore my comment if all the non spammy nodes were reverted. |
53114647 | almost 8 years ago | For instance, this has a slightly "positive tone" but seems to be a 100% valid node: osm.org/node/5109075827
|
53114647 | almost 8 years ago | I think the algorithm is horrible. |
53065944 | almost 8 years ago | All fixed:
|
53065944 | almost 8 years ago | Hi matresh, you've made some very destructive edits, but you then fixed them and also some good edits. (You forgot fixing some of them and I'm fixing them now). Is everything OK? |
53064091 | almost 8 years ago | Reverted obviously bad edit. |
53065944 | almost 8 years ago | I suspect the user is intentionally vandalizing. |
53044107 | almost 8 years ago | You forgot junction=roundabout |