OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
57254988 about 7 years ago

osm.org/node/1803078782

57254988 about 7 years ago

שלום. הזזת את תחנת האוטובוס כ-35 מטר מהמקום המדווח על ידי משרד התחבורה. האם אתה בטוח שהשינוי תקין?

57254988 about 7 years ago

Hello. You moved the bus stop about 35 meters from the reported ministry of transportation position. Are you sure this is correct?

60401550 about 7 years ago

שלום ותודה על העריכות. נא להימנע מהוספת פרסומות למפה. תודה.

59288455 about 7 years ago

אני מסכים שזה לא סטנדרטי - במובן שלרוב לא משתמשים בזה כאן. בכל מקרה אני מציע לך לדון בזה בפורום.
.
אני לא רואה סיבה למה לתת טיפול מיוחד אך ורק לתחנות האוטובוס. אם באמת יוחלט שצריך סטנדרזציה, ניתן לעשות שינוי גלובלי לכל השמות במפה, כולל התחנות.
.
לי אישית העניין לא מפריע. יש בעייתיות במצב הנוכחי?

59288455 about 7 years ago

משרד התחבורה*

59288455 about 7 years ago

יש לציין שאי אפשר לשנות שמות תחנות אוטובוס מיובאות. סקריפט הייבוא כבר דרס לך את השמות והחזיר את השם המקורי.
.
השם של תחנת אוטובוס מהווה מידע רשמי שנמצא בשימוש בכל האפליקציות והשירותים אחרים, כולל מערכת הכריזה באוטובוס ומידע על מסכים דיגיטלים בתחנות.
.
כדי לשנות שם, יש לשנות אותו קודם במאגר מידע התחבורה על ידי יצירת קשר איתם. הסקריפט ייבא את השם החדש אוטומטית.
.
מידע נוסף: osm.wiki/User:SafwatHalaby/scripts/gtfs

29710467 about 7 years ago

Hello. You've added a stop (osm.org/node/3416365928) which is not present in the Ministry of Transportation data. However, there's a similar stop slightly north of here (osm.org/node/5210715407). Do you think that's a duplicate? Or are these two separate stops?

59700642 about 7 years ago

Hello Ynhockey! Your name change to osm.org/node/1803011231 (bus stop ref: 54) has been automatically reverted by the bus stop update script.
.
The reason behind this is explained in osm.wiki/User:SafwatHalaby/scripts/gtfs#Limited_name_tag_editing

55494104 about 7 years ago

Hello, this is another edit where you moved a bus stop a large distance. Are you sure this is correct?
.
osm.org/node/1803002972

54375306 about 7 years ago

Hello, in this edit, you have moved a bus stop hundreds of meters from the reported Ministry of Transportation position. Are you sure it's correct?
.
osm.org/node/5210707648

57792287 about 7 years ago

Hello and welcome to OSM. It appears you have moved some bus stops and roads into unreasonable locations. You've also added nonexisting points of interest.
.
Could you refrain from editing the map further before discussing the reasoning behind your edits?

58623140 about 7 years ago

Hello! In this edit, you have moved a bus stop. But it is now 400 meters away from the Ministry of Transportation data.
.
Are you sure this is correct?

58785949 about 7 years ago

There won't be a dispute. I am not strongly in favor of a particular tagging method. I merely wanted to point out that highway=path + footway=crossing is not correct.
.
I do agree that highway=footway and bicycle=yes can be a bit messy, and while "any tag you like" is allowed, it is usually recommended to use established tags, and one needs to check how the new tags affect different editors / viewers.
.
Are there well-established alternatives to highway=footway, footway=crossing, bicycle=dismount?

58785949 about 7 years ago

On a more general note, I am not sure the global community agrees that highway=path equals highway=footway + bicycle=yes.
.
A footway is mainly for people, it may or may not allow bikes. A path is generic.
.
The way crossings are tagged (they are mainly footways) exemplifies this. there is a footway=crossing tag but no path=crossing tag.

58785949 about 7 years ago

I am referring to highway=crossing nodes linked with a way which has both highway=footway and footway=crossing. After your edits, the way now has highway=path, footway=crossing which is invalid tagging. See: osm.wiki/Tag:footway%3Dcrossing

This has occurred in older bulk edits too. I think you simply need to exclude ways that also carry footway=crossing or that are connected to highway=crossing nodes.

Take a look at the main streets in Daliat el carmel for instance. most crossings were affected.
osm.org/#map=14/32.6896/35.0607

58766991 about 7 years ago

e.g. osm.org/node/925551615

58766991 about 7 years ago

wikipedia=en:קבוצת דלק does not make sense. I think you meant wikipedia=he: קבוצת דלק

58785949 about 7 years ago

As discussed earlier, these edits seem to be bad for crossings.

57536223 over 7 years ago

Hello. The "name" tags in Israel should usually be Hebrew.
.
osm.org/way/49618415