OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
123562235 over 2 years ago

Hello and welcome to OSM!,
Please don't "label" routes like this. Many of the ways that make up the Pennine Way have other names; many are also part of other routes.
If the name of a route is in OSM, then maps that want to can use that, for example https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#18/53.36923/-1.82544
(there the route name is in purple the thing in brackets is the local footpath reference, and the duplicated Pennine Way name in black is the name added in this changeset).
Also see e.g. https://hiking.waymarkedtrails.org/#?map=11.0/53.3745/-1.7819 .
Best Regards,
Andy
PS: any questions, please don't hesitate to ask!

130894549 over 2 years ago

Hello,
I think that you might have accidentially added the quiet_lane designation to the wrong thing on osm.org/way/539425190 . That's an admin boundary; presumably you meant to add to the road?
There's a list of ones to check at https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1rn8 , which includes a hedge and a fence.
Best Regards,
Andy

15200924 over 2 years ago

Hello,
Are these osm.org/node/2178765359/history wells or water tanks? I'd have thought that they were fairly different structures.
Best Regards,
Andy

82204220 over 2 years ago

Hello,
I'm not convinced that "designation" is ideal for osm.org/way/781397657/history - it already has intermittent=yes; "designation" is normally used for legal designations.
Best Regards,
Andy

74844858 over 2 years ago

Hello,
Does designation make sense for e.g. osm.org/way/727695757/history here? "designation" is normally used for a legal status; this is just a private track on a golf course.
Best Regards,
Andy

87133710 over 2 years ago

Hello,
On osm.org/way/723321902/history you've changed "designation=cart_path" to "designation=golf_cart_path". I can see the logic, but I don't think that either make sense - it's just a private track on a golf course.
Best Regards,
Andy

17381953 over 2 years ago

Hello,
What's the significance of "designation=The Co-operative Food" on e.g. osm.org/way/219994751/history ? It now has brand, name, operator - and designation.
Best Regards,
Andy

17440673 over 2 years ago

Hello,
What does "designation=H.41" mean on e.g. osm.org/way/234173832 ?
Best Regards,
Andy

108492609 over 2 years ago

Hello,
What actually is osm.org/node/8944109703 ? It's defined as "historic=archaeological_site" with "designation=March Stone". What actually is a "March Stone"? Is it some sort of megalith, or something else?
Best Regards,
Andy

20067683 over 2 years ago

Hello,
What's the significance of "designation=Historic Mill" on e.g. osm.org/node/2627192242/history here?
Best Regards,
Andy

117329397 over 2 years ago

Bonjour,
Cela ressemble beaucoup à un montage mécanique. Pouvez-vous indiquer où cela a été discuté avec la communauté OSM au sens large ?
Cordialement,
Andy
(voir aussi https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/maproulette-request-for-comments-liking-and-flagging-challenges/5838/2 pour info)

117329397 over 2 years ago

Hello,
This looks very much like a mechanical edits. Can you point to where it was discussed with the wider OSM community?
Best Regards,
Andy
(see also https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/maproulette-request-for-comments-liking-and-flagging-challenges/5838/2 for info)

111922887 over 2 years ago

Your change to osm.org/way/3753061/history . This doesn't look to me another like a regular amenity=parking at all. It's likely an area of hard standing used for dropping off crops to be collected (e.g. historically beet for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Sugar in Peterborough) or storing anything before spreading on fields.
Making armchair changes such as this significantly REDUCES the quality of OpenStreetMap - don't do it.

129598993 over 2 years ago

Sources here are primarily knowing how Ben will have mapped it 15 years ago (from survey, but without later access to aerial imagery), and knowing the (invalid) reason that Fred73000 will have added an amenity-parking tag in osm.org/changeset/111922887 .

129059886 over 2 years ago

Actually, you probably want to _add_ a denomination tag rather than removing the religion one here.

126599332 almost 3 years ago

This changeset reverts some or all edits made in changesets 71207555, 71549045, 72076256, 72077397, 72077684, 72077905, 72204939, 72222097, 72222523, 72222664, 72223141, 72223431, 72223506, 72225763, 72226044, 72226597, 72244916, 72245219, 72245975, 72246723, 72250185, 72251855, 72287981, 72329188, 72329215, 73091023, 73091311, 73091674, 73091690, 73091770, 73093450, 73093624, 73093853, 73093865, 73093882, 73100053, 73130872, 73130914, 73131492, 73131627, 73131832, 73132397, 73133375, 73133419, 73133709, 73133790, 73133812, 73133829, 73134107, 73134166, 73135979, 73136121, 73136142, 73136221, 73136283, 73136414, 73136715, 73136723, 73136849, 73141352, 73141422, 73142729, 73143540, 73173622, 73173673, 73173693, 73173873, 73173888, 73173913, 73176360, 73176378, 73176417, 73176428, 73176448, 73176468, 73176777, 73176789, 73176807, 73177461, 73177475, 73177520, 73177530, 73177554, 73177596, 73177911, 73177941, 73177962, 73177987, 73178054, 73178062, 73178458, 73178470, 73178558, 73178770, 73178892, 73179295, 73179500, 73180181, 73181017, 73181186, 73181325, 73181732, 73181802, 73182373, 73182422, 73182702, 73182858, 73183073, 73252681, 73252764, 73252819, 73252847, 73252850, 73252866, 73252969, 73253047, 73253054, 73253065, 73253147, 73253166, 73253220, 73253295, 73253317, 73253335, 73253353, 73253372, 73253381, 73253514, 73253529, 73253534, 73253578, 73253660, 73253689, 73253703, 73253716, 73253731, 73253744, 73253755, 73253757, 73253788, 73253796, 73253830, 73253858, 73253881, 73253888, 73254165, 73254175, 73254224, 73254243, 73254262, 73254285, 73254303, 73254315, 73254434, 73254603, 73254698, 73254808, 73254822, 73254984, 73254988, 73255006, 73255016, 73255077, 73255103, 73255108, 73255114, 73255131, 73255155, 73255215, 73255237, 73258051, 73258159, 73258171, 73286870, 73286894, 73286907, 73286942, 73286954, 73287026, 73287047, 73287063, 73287184, 73287192, 73287235, 73287259, 73287388, 73287412, 73287775, 73287782, 73287795, 73287836, 73287859, 73287892, 73287906, 73288573, 73288606, 73288636, 73288683, 73288753, 73288806, 73288836, 73288917, 73292953, 73293109, 73293201, 73293364, 73332679, 73367447, 73729247, 73729398, 73729665, 73730163, 73730223, 73730316, 73730515, 73730569, 73730600, 73730725, 73730855, 73736796, 73737071, 73738028, 73738960, 73739797, 73740143, 73740280, 73740446, 73740564, 73740676, 73740713, 73740766, 73821569, 73823118, 73823720, 73825814, 73827061, 73827608, 73860284, 73860559, 73860608, 73861209, 73861552, 73861644, 73862101, 73863872, 73864686, 73864980, 73865696, 73866230, 73866355, 73866390, 73866401, 73866424, 73867078, 73868058, 73868771, 73871448, 73902061, 73902539, 73903374, 73904338, 73905853, 73910029, 73910760, 73911280, 73986068, 73986177, 73990842, 73991714, 73991886, 74016220, 74016582, 74017535, 74017563, 74017602, 74017717, 74017816, 74017884, 74018250, 74018529, 74019003, 74019352, 74019409, 74019785, 74019808, 74019850, 74019906, 74021622, 74021683, 74021735, 74022918, 74023220, 74023266, 74023776, 74023927, 74024011, 74024109, 74024607, 74024771, 74024936, 74025070, 74025420, 74025695, 74025895, 74026414, 74027068, 74027174, 74027211, 74027351, 74027424, 74027526, 74027773, 74028094, 74060554, 74061016, 74061096, 74061142, 74061171, 74061221, 74061375, 74061385, 74061402, 74061424, 74061430, 74061442, 74061465, 74061587, 74061606, 74061612, 74061657, 74061671, 74061896, 74062063, 74062122, 74062159, 74062164, 74062373, 74062959, 74063107, 74069629, 74073310, 74108846, 74109431, 74109616, 74109799, 74110173, 74111866, 74112849, 74113670, 74113780, 74114082, 74115721, 74115856, 74115995, 74153115, 74154307.

73093865 almost 3 years ago

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126599332 where the changeset comment is: Reverting some names from a suspect source; see osm.org/user_blocks/6295

73136723 almost 3 years ago

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126599332 where the changeset comment is: Reverting some names from a suspect source; see osm.org/user_blocks/6295

74061587 almost 3 years ago

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126599332 where the changeset comment is: Reverting some names from a suspect source; see osm.org/user_blocks/6295

73902539 almost 3 years ago

This changeset has been reverted fully or in part by changeset 126599332 where the changeset comment is: Reverting some names from a suspect source; see osm.org/user_blocks/6295