OpenStreetMap 标志 OpenStreetMap

The New York Times has maps tracking the Russian invasion of Ukraine. I wondered what the data source of the first one was: were they maybe using OSM?

New York Times map of attacks on Kharkiv

Mappers on the #openstreetmap IRC channel quickly found some differences. Just to be absolutely sure, I used the QuickOSM plugin for QGIS to download OSM data for the area from overpass. I then quickly styled the map, using the colour picker to copy the Times map. In half an hour, I had my own map of Kharkiv.

OSM-based version of the same map

The maps are quite different. The OSM-based one has more roads, especially in the forest. The land use is more accurate and up to date. The Ukraine community has done a great job.

The New York Times isn’t using OpenStreetMap, but an inferior, probably commercial source. Otherwise, their map would be better ;).

位置: Новобаварський район, Kharkiv, Kharkiv Urban Hromada, Kharkiv Raion, Kharkiv Oblast, Ukraine
电子邮件图标 Bluesky图标 Facebook图标 LinkedIn图标 Mastodon图标 Telegram图标 X图标

讨论

lalolan2022年03月 3日 18:34 的评论

Russia is using it, at least “for the camera”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1OIf-b9aX3I Compare background map with osm.org/#map=7/46.932/31.816 specially in Sea of Azov borders.

jose_ecu2022年03月 4日 18:17 的评论

Bad people using a good idea.

Sammyhawkrad2022年03月13日 09:05 的评论

It could possibly be an old export of OpenStreetMap

登录以留下评论