Should this be merged with osm.org/relation/9507742 ?
Seems like the same to me

What happened to my comment!?
Add detailed footways and crossings around Oxford Road / Otley Road junction.

Hi Mike. Just spotted 3 more near Guiseley Wells.
http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/19wO
Hope that link works

Thanks. I've changed that bit and added some walls. osm.org/changeset/104379857#map=17/53.86463/-1.72542

Thanks for pointing that out, I'd forgotten about it. There isn't anything similar up at the road end is there. It's just one big opening

Hi Malcolm

Where you've added a footpath next to the farm track to Hollins Hill farm, usually that would just be joined to the track at either end and the designation added to the track. I'll fix this unless there's a reason for having it separate?

Okay, thanks. Yes, I remember it being up, I can't remember how I got up. I guess there must have been something or I probably wouldn't have marked it as a stile. But maybe it's now been removed. Cheers again for looking.

Thanks for checking. When you say a gap, do you mean a big gap or a squeezer (examples on osm.wiki/Tag:barrier%3Dstile#Stile_details )
I'll have to go back and take a look, I was too busy avoiding the cows last time for photos!

Oh good 🙂 Or maybe both exist and can be walked depending on the whim of the farmer?

Okay, no worries. I'll try and see if it's still there next time I'm out that way

👍 Footway is also what I use. You can also add informal=yes for desire lines and the like

I know, it's awkward seeing changes on OSM isn't it. It's osm.org/node/7771217026 but that doesn't help much!
If you have a look at https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=96432816 or https://osmhv.openstreetmap.de/changeset.jsp?id=96432816 and zoom into the footpath on the west of the Hollins Hill Road, the footpath used to cross a wall on the way to the bridleway.

I think what you've added is also there but when I walked that way was blocked by a temporary electric fence if I remember right, but there was a stile I went over.

In general, I think if you're going to change / delete something that's already on the map it's worth looking at whether it was just added by someone using Bing or from a 'survey', and how recent it was.

Thanks

Thanks Malcolm. Yeah, it's something I've struggled with and unfortunately there isn't a straightforward answer overall. However, in this case there is. If it's a pavement beside a road it should be highway=footway; footway=sidewalk (they use the American term because it has a specific meaning). I think it doesn't help that iD uses path and footpath.
My basic understanding is always footway where it's illegal to cycle. Some people like footway almost everywhere, some people like path for informal paths or like through a park. I think as long as we're consistent around here it doesn't matter much. Cheers!

Hi Malcolm
Is part of this unpaved? osm.org/way/896287178
Also, I think it and the one on the other side of Coppice Wood Avenue would be better tagged as highway=footway; footway=sidewalk.

Thanks

Hi Malcolm. The stile I added existed in July last year. Has it been removed?

Cheers :)

Hi Mike

Grave yards? osm.org/way/929536561
osm.org/way/929536571

Thanks. I've added the wikidata tag osm.org/changeset/102828058 . I may update the wikidata page but got daunted first time around!

P.S. I thought you knocked the conversation about level of mapping detail on talk-gb into a cocked hat :)

Thanks very much Mike. The sign certainly exists: https://postimg.cc/PvZVpzXY The arrow, and its position on the path side of the wall, has me think that it isn't referring to the road at the back of Belle Vue Terrace. See also https://postimg.cc/5HrM8gVR

So, I think change what is currently called Green Terrace to be an unnamed highway=service, service=alley; name the path and the building outline.

You ask a good question about Belle Vue Terrace. I had been thinking that because the road was at the front of the houses it was okay as a highway=residential, but now I look again, it's more like a parking area to the side of the highway=service that runs to the mechanics yard at the back of the theatre: https://postimg.cc/Q9WZm7Nx
Here's the road that continues on to the mechanic's yard https://postimg.cc/t1Jj1fL6
and here's some bollards near the entrance from The Green https://postimg.cc/pmqvLx1x

Looking on the web, the addresses for those businesses are given as Unit #, Belle Vue Terrace, so it seems it would be legitimate to move it to be the road that goes into that yard, either as a highway=service or a highway=residential?