OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
143933492 over 1 year ago

Like I said I was pretty sure this is SEO spam (it seems that many businesses added by brand-new accounts are). The bad thing is that I don't know how I can be 100% sure it's not legitimate. I want to give people the benefit of the doubt so I've been asking them in a comment, then marking it in OSMCha to go back later and remove if they don't reply. Maybe you're right that I'm wasting my time though...

145167732 over 1 year ago

Got er fixed!

145019609 over 1 year ago

I went over your other recent changes too. Looks great to me! Thanks for your additions - this is valuable info!

145023098 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Everything looks good to me! One very minor thing you may want to change - it's best to be explicit for every day of the week on opening_hours tag. That means putting the days the office is closed too. (Mo-Fr 08:30-17:30; Sa-Su off)
Thanks again and happy mapping!

145167732 over 1 year ago

Oh geez. I'm not too familiar with revert tools so looks like I just removed Upper Wasabi as a conflict. Let me just do it in JOSM when I get home, haha. Sorry about that.

145167732 over 1 year ago

Gotcha. No problem! There are tools to revert changes like this. Looks like any geometrical adjustment you made was lost (since the deletion was in the same changeset as any geometric changes), so you'll have to start over on that I think. But we can un-delete it. :)

145023263 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Looks like a few things are wrong here:
- You removed highway=* tags from a couple roads. Those are necessary to mark things as roads. Looks like another mapper already fixed your Twain Ave removal.
- It seems like the towing company you added might be misplaced or spam. Can you give a source that this is really accurate info? (In-person survey is a valid source.) If this is your business that you run from your home, it's debatable whether the info is appropriate for OSM. Perhaps a relevant test might be, if someone showed up here, could they be served in-person?
- The Description tag should be a concise description of the feature rather than a free-form ad space.

I fixed what I could here. Let me know what you think about the placement thing. Thanks again and happy mapping!

145031294 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Looks good to me, no complaints!

145050902 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Everything looks good to me! Thanks again and happy mapping.

145097633 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Looks good overall, here are a couple of minor issues:
- Ways should generally be connected wherever it makes sense that one could travel between them. That means the path should connect to the highway somehow even if seems a little wonky.
- For something like this parking lot, if it's signed or officially labeled somehow as Pete's Pile Parking, name=* tag is best. However, if that's more of a casual name that the locals might refer to it by, the loc_name=* is better.

I went ahead and made those changes. (OSM can have somewhat of a wild west attitude to certain things... So not everyone might agree on my ideas. But I do my best to follow generally accepted best practices.)
Thanks again and happy mapping!

145099094 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Everything looks good to me! One minor thing you may want to change - it's best to be explicit for every day of the week on opening_hours tag. That means putting the days the office is closed too. (Mo-Fr 09:00-17:00; Sa-Su off)
Thanks again and happy mapping!

145108918 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. The Description tag should be a concise description of the feature rather than a free-form ad space. Also, opening hours tag follows a specific syntax. It can be a little tricky but using this format makes it machine-readable, meaning apps and whatnot can parse it reliably.
I went ahead and made those corrections. Thanks again, and welcome to OSM!

145122674 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Everything looks good to me - no problems! Happy mapping.

145128494 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Looks great overall, the only issue being a minor omission of a semicolon and closed days of the week on the opening_hours. I added those.
Thanks again and welcome to OSM!

145137276 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes.
I don't know too much about aviation - are FBOs aircraft fuel stations, as in petrol? If so, looks like the tag to use would be aeroway=fuel: osm.wiki/Tag:aeroway%3Dfuel
I can add that if you want, just let me know.
Thanks again and welcome to OSM!

145138705 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. Looks great, thanks for the correction.

Just a note, TIGER tags are somewhat vestigial - they were added when a bunch of streets were imported like 15 years ago. In the future, if you feel like the info is correct you can actually just remove them if you want. If you do want to keep them around, I'd suggest not modifying them so that later mappers can see what the original import suggested. (But I generally just delete them. :) )

Anyway, thanks again and welcome to OSM!

145144612 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes.

It seems like this might be misplaced or spam. Can you give a source that this is really accurate info? (In-person survey is a valid source.)

- The Description tag should be a concise description of the feature rather than a free-form ad space.
- Opening hours tag follows a specific syntax. It can be a little tricky but using this format makes it machine-readable, meaning apps and whatnot can parse it reliably.
- Other tags like address also follow specific formats for the same reasons.

I went ahead and made those changes. Thanks again, and welcome to OSM!

145163401 over 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for your contribution! Since you requested a review, I looked over your changes. That looks good to me! (Also, wow, someone really went crazy with the parking lots around here...)

145167732 over 1 year ago

For large deletions like this, it's best to be 100% sure - Have you visited this in person? I guess Strava heatmap is pretty reliable so if you haven't been there, this might still be OK as long as Strava really shows absolutely nothing.

145168228 over 1 year ago

Actually, looking a little closer, it seems like Lower Wasabi has an issue since it's one-way and not connected to anything on the north side. If you've been there in person, do you know if this connects to anything?