OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
152376100 about 1 year ago

Hi! I see you added an overlapping building feature for the Maverik Stadium bleachers. Have you ever been here in person to confirm that? Last time I observed these on-site, the seating area wasn't a building, there's no way to go inside/under it, and it doesn't extend upward from the ground.

The OSM wiki says about the building= tag:
"In OpenStreetMap, a building is a man-made structure with a roof, standing more or less permanently in one place."
The Maverik Stadium bleachers don't have a roof. Because of that and the other things I've mentioned, you shouldn't tag them as a building.
Thanks, and please let me know your thoughts.

152009298 about 1 year ago

Regarding map updates, how long it takes for updates to appear depends on what map you're looking at. For openstreetmap.org, an update should appear within 10-30 mins. But if you're using some third party app or something, updates can range from near-instant to months or years. What is your map of interest?

152009298 about 1 year ago

My suggestions were mostly referring to the roads you added called "x access" such as "south canyon access". I'm asking if that's the actual real name of the road? And if not, that data is still valuable but we can put it under other tags as appropriate. We just shouldn't use the name tag to describe a feature. The name tag should only be for the actual name.

152009298 about 1 year ago

Hi, and welcome to OpenStreetMap! Nice additions here - contributions like this are really valuable for hikers since a lot of external services draw from OSM for paths and stuff.
Generally, the name tag is for the official or "common" name of a feature. That means it might appear on a signpost or map board or something. If not, you might consider using other related tags like `loc_name` (for informal names that a local might use casually) or `destination`. (see osm.wiki/Key:destination)

Let me know if you have any input or questions. I haven't modified any of the stuff you added, just want to get your thoughts. Thanks again for your work here, and welcome to OSM!

152013339 about 1 year ago

That field (osm.org/way/29267479) is too small to play American football on. I think they use it for marching band practice or something.

152162755 about 1 year ago

Nice addition! I didn't know natural=earth_bank was a thing. There are definitely some other natural=cliffs in the area that would be better described by that tag too.

51040082 about 1 year ago

Hi James! I forgot to comment here, but you're correct that this was a mistake in a changeset number. I already revert-reverted, see osm.org/changeset/152005157 .
Sorry about the confusion!

151968988 about 1 year ago

Oh, wow, alright!

151920711 about 1 year ago

No worries. I removed the duplicate.

151921236 about 1 year ago

Hmm, if one is good, two must be better!

151920711 about 1 year ago

Hi, and welcome to OpenStreetMap! It looks like there's already a nearby trailhead feature, just north of here. Is that the one you had in mind when adding this? Let me know. And thanks for your contribution!

151985014 about 1 year ago

Hi, I've reverted your edit because it appears to be misplaced or spam. If you think I'm incorrect, please comment here or message me and we can get your business correctly listed ASAP!
If you represent a marketing or SEO company, You'll need to make some changes to your process. Please ask me or another member of the community what can be done to best help your clients.

osm.org/changeset/152005699

152005157 about 1 year ago

See comments at osm.org/changeset/152004946

152004946 about 1 year ago

Oh, I accidentally reverted changeset 51040082 instead of 151040082. Sorry about the large bbox.

152004946 about 1 year ago

Uh oh. Something's wrong here... What did I mess up? Looking into it.

151169911 about 1 year ago

Hi there! I've reverted your changes because this appears to be severely misplaced or spam. If that seems wrong to you, please comment here or message me and we can get your legitimate business listed correctly on OSM!
If you represent a marketing company or similar, please review your process for adding features to OSM before continuing. Feel free to message me with any questions.

osm.org/changeset/152004946

51040082 about 1 year ago

Hi there! I've reverted your changes because this appears to be severely misplaced or spam. If that seems wrong to you, please comment here or message me and we can get your legitimate business listed correctly on OSM!
If you represent a marketing company or similar, please review your process for adding features to OSM before continuing. Feel free to message me with any questions.

osm.org/changeset/152004946

151968988 about 1 year ago

Wait, Sweeto Burrito is back? In the same location even?

151122743 about 1 year ago

Hi, and welcome to OpenStreetMap! Your edits here look great to me. Thanks for your contribution!

151081472 about 1 year ago

Nice additions!!