OpenStreetMap logoa OpenStreetMap

Bus and other relations

andywcoder erabiltzaileak 7 Urtarrila 2011 datan argitaratua English hizkuntzan

Please use the roles 'forward' and 'backward' if you create routes that don't follow the same ways in both directions. And check that all the ways are nicely connected and in the right order. JOSM is a great tool to create routes. Read osm.wiki/Relation:route if you're not sure how to do it right.

I wrote a small script that converts a single osm relation of ways into a kml. That lets you view routes in google earth or google maps. It doesn't work with super-relations but it should work well with roles. Check it out: http://www.jrq.ch/osmrelations/

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Eztabaida

Richard erabiltzailearen iruzkina 7 Urtarrila 2011 23:35-eann

"check that all the ways are nicely connected and in the right order"

Don't be silly. Any programmer worth their salt can sort route relations into the right order. Mappers are our most valuable commodity; we shoudn't impose additional burdens on them to help lazy programmers. Route relations are not required to be ordered and nor should they be.

flaimo erabiltzailearen iruzkina 8 Urtarrila 2011 03:17-eann

actually the new mapping scheme makes roles unnecessary: osm.wiki/Proposed_features/Public_Transport

andywcoder erabiltzailearen iruzkina 8 Urtarrila 2011 08:17-eann

@flaimo I really like the idea for making every route variant/direction a own relation. Saves a lot of trouble.

Hasi saioa iruzkin bat uzteko