Boot scrapers have fascinated me since Helge Schneider’s musical “Mendy das Wusical” in which they play a very important role. #stiefelabstreifkante (It’s a somewhat absurd musical by my favourite German comedian…)
I remember that when I moved to Ireland I kept sending my sister pictures of the ones I came across, because she also likes the musical and the comedian.
For some years now I have been thinking that it would be interesting to map them. Partly because I wanted to know how many there are in Kilkenny and where and also, you never know who might be interested in this data in the future, so OpenStreetMap is the obvious choice to record them.
A.-K. D., CC BY-SA 4.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
At this point, if you get tired of reading - I’ve made a video about it: watch video on YouTube
I didn’t want to map them as nodes by themselves, because I didn’t want to clutter the map with nodes that are of very little interest to most people, and because it happens too easily that you move a node by mistake when moving the map in iD. So instead, I decided to add a key boot_scraper
to the entrance key. This had the productive side effect that I had to map (most of) the entrances first. Some had already been mapped. I decided to follow a similar pattern to the sidewalk
key to say whether there was a boot scraper left or right of the entrance or on both sides. If you’re really mad into recording them, you could also use was:boot_scraper
where you can see traces of them on the steps, but I’m not planning on doing that all the time.
A.-K. D., CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
According to the situation in Kilkenny, boot scrapers are found outside Georgian buildings which means you could also add building:architecture=georgian
, if you wanted to be thorough.
I noticed after a few entrances that many of them had a step where you enter through the door, so I decided to add a step_count
to the entrance as well. Many Georgian houses also have more steps outside (I don’t know if that’s because they were paranoid about floods or if they wanted the option of having windows in their basements and needed an elevated ground floor). So I made a point to map these as well to help mapping accessibility.
(See also my previous diary post about steps in the housename:etymology.)
I have not documented the key on the wiki, because I don’t want to document something I’m the only user of - not too often anyway- , so as soon as someone else uses it, I will. ;-)
Discussion
Comment from valhikes on 8 October 2023 at 14:49
Because the fungus that kills Port Orford Cedars also affects tanoaks quite badly, the parks of the Midpeninsula Regional Parks (south of San Francisco, California) have provided boot scrapers at a number of their trailheads. Knocking the mud off prevents the spread and saves their tanoaks, or so they hope. These aren’t associated with any entrances, but they did all have information signs they would be right or left of. They weren’t quite as cool as these, either.
Comment from b-unicycling on 8 October 2023 at 16:18
@valhikes: I mapped them from my “cultural background”, but interesting to hear that they are finding a sort of revival. As long as the tag can be added to something they’re associated with or attached to, all is well, I think.
Comment from AntiCompositeNumber on 9 October 2023 at 01:54
There are some surviving boot scrapers near me, mostly on Colonial Georgian and Federal-style buildings. I could only remember the location of one, but I’m sure I’ll find more if I finish surveying for historical markers.
The tagging of
boot_scraper=left/right/both
makes sense, but it’s probably important to specify that it’s from the perspective facing the door.Comment from b-unicycling on 9 October 2023 at 08:54
I forgot to mention it here, but I said it in the video:
left/right
is always seen as going into the door, because that is when you use the boot scraper.Comment from motogs on 15 October 2023 at 17:12
How would you suggest relating this to amenity=boot_cleaner or any other method used hitherto for representing boot cleaners, such as those found at the exits from parks or playing fields? Many of these are brushes instead of - or as well as - scrapers. I’ve used amenity=boot_cleaner for this purpose but I’d be happy to change them all to something equally or more appropriate in order to maintain consistency with your scraper tagging.
Comment from b-unicycling on 16 October 2023 at 10:28
@motogs: That is a fair point. The 6
amenity=boot_scraper
that are already mapped are also in that park context. I have no problem with separating the two uses, because boot scrapers in “my” sense are used when entering a place and are strictly associated with entrances, because that was my approach, whereas the boot cleaners in nature are of a different date and somewhat purpose, more variety in how the cleaning is done and being used when leaving a place (always?). I wouldn’t mind if the nature ones (scrapers and brushes) are all mapped asamenity=boot_cleaner
. I think they can also sometimes found at farms to prevent the spread of BSE and things like that, but I’m not sure if they’re not a type of bath for wellies and how permanently they are installed.I will move this also to the talk page on the wiki, because I would have to re-write the page in parts, if we come to an agreement.
Comment from derloris on 28 October 2023 at 21:14
Great mapping idea, thanks! Is there a way to map a handle of a boot scraper, like here? https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Door_scrapers_in_Austria#/media/File:Door_scraper,_Sechshauser_Stra%C3%9Fe_97,_Vienna.jpg
Comment from b-unicycling on 28 October 2023 at 22:09
Interesting case, I haven’t come across those, but a lot in Kilkenny are integrated into fences, so you could hold on to the fence. Back to your question, maybe a
boot_scraper:handle=yes
?Comment from derloris on 29 October 2023 at 02:17
Ok, sounds good!