only numeric values are allowed for maxspeed. So I removed
some maxspeed=no at the A555 near Colonge.
The effect of the tag was the motorway disappearing from
the AllInOne Garmin map......
OpenStreetMap
only numeric values are allowed for maxspeed. So I removed
some maxspeed=no at the A555 near Colonge.
The effect of the tag was the motorway disappearing from
the AllInOne Garmin map......
Diskussioun
Bemierkung vum TomH de(n) 28. Mee 2009 um 21:46 Auer
I think you'll find there's no such thing as an "allowed" or "not allowed" value for a tag - we're not proscriptive about such things.
Bemierkung vum Tordanik de(n) 28. Mee 2009 um 23:11 Auer
How about fixing the bug in that Garmin map conversion instead? There is no such thing as "allowed" tags in OSM, so applications have to be able to deal with unknown tags.
Bemierkung vum Richard de(n) 29. Mee 2009 um 06:48 Auer
Alphanumeric tags are very common in maxspeed, anyhow. It's the convention in the UK to tag as (say) maxspeed=30mph.
Bemierkung vum grenzdebil_bonn de(n) 30. Mee 2009 um 12:05 Auer
Hi! Please revert this edit! maxspeed=no(ne) is absolutely common and there is a difference between this and a road without a maxspeed tag.
Thank you!
Bemierkung vum chris66 de(n) 31. Mee 2009 um 15:01 Auer
The voting for maxspeed=no/none was REJECTED :
osm.wiki/Proposed_features/maxspeed_none
@grenzdebil: with the same argument I could map not existing highways
with highway=no. Doesn't make too much sense.
Chris
Bemierkung vum grenzdebil_bonn de(n) 1. Juni 2009 um 19:54 Auer
@Chris66: no. maxspeed=* refers to the maxspeed rule applying to some section of a road - and this is exactly what was tagged here in the first place. If you don't like it, please come up with some other way of tagging "no speed limit applying here" before deleting other people's work.
The new Version of the Garmin map in question works with maxspeed=no, by the way.
Bemierkung vum grenzdebil_bonn de(n) 1. Juni 2009 um 19:55 Auer
@Chris66: no. maxspeed=* refers to the maxspeed rule applying to some section of a road - and this is exactly what was tagged here in the first place. If you don't like it, please come up with some other way of tagging "no speed limit applying here" before deleting other people's work.
The new Version of the Garmin map in question works with maxspeed=no, by the way.