compdude's Comments
Changeset | When | Comment |
---|---|---|
90139764 | almost 5 years ago | Historic Route 66 does not qualify as a trunk road. Current standard practice in the US is to tag a road as a trunk road only if it is divided with at grade intersections (i.e. one step down from a freeway). Again, please change it back to how it was before. |
91241306 | almost 5 years ago | Please make sure you don't tag administrative areas such as this relation (osm.org/relation/187249) as a building. The building=yes should only be used to represent a building's footprint. I'm assuming you just made a mistake here, so I'm going to go ahead and remove the building=yes tag from the administrative boundary relation. |
86833183 | almost 5 years ago | Not all of Loop 338 should be tagged as a motorway; the motorway tag should only be used for roads that are actually freeways. Please change it back to how it was before, thanks! |
89599850 | almost 5 years ago | Hello, and welcome to OpenStreetMap! In case you weren't aware, the general consensus in the US is that roads should be tagged as highway=trunk if they are a high-speed divided highway with at-grade intersections. (i.e. almost a freeway) This means that I-15 Business should not be tagged as a trunk road as it doesn't meet those requirements. Please change it back to how it was before, thanks! |
89391271 | almost 5 years ago | Noticed you retagged some of the heath as farmland. Not sure if that's correct; didn't think there was any farmland in this area. |
89390633 | almost 5 years ago | It looks like you changed some of the natural=heath in this area to landuse=farmland, which I don't think is correct either. (pretty sure there's no farmland here in the middle of the desert) |
73816701 | almost 5 years ago | Is this road still closed? |
87894057 | about 5 years ago | Please stop changing the name of this city. You have done this multiple times, and that is considered vandalism. Please stop doing this in the future. |
88000815 | about 5 years ago | This should not be tagged as motorcycle parking. Only stalls specifically intended for motorcycles should be tagged with this tag. |
88000877 | about 5 years ago | If a road is closed for construction, the construction=* tag should be construction=primary (or whatever the highway=* tag was--in this case it was tagged as highway=primary, so you should use the construction=primary tag). You tagged it as construction=minor, which has caused this road to disappear from the map. Also construction=minor is not a valid tag--see osm.wiki/Key:construction for valid tags to use on highways under construction. I would appreciate it if you fixed this, thanks! Also, you tagged the opening date as 2020-07-15. Is this correct? |
88031639 | about 5 years ago | Again, please don't tag an area as a building unless that area actually represents the building's footprint, thanks! |
88033533 | about 5 years ago | Please don't tag an area as a building unless that area actually represents a building's footprint. Please remove the building=yes tag, thanks! |
87546573 | about 5 years ago | You're not supposed to tag an area as a building unless it actually represents the footprint of a building. Please edit this area and remove the building=yes tag. Also, please don't put names in all caps. |
86107244 | about 5 years ago | Please be more careful when you are editing tags for existing roads. You changed part of SR 66 to service when it should be secondary. |
86753360 | about 5 years ago | This ramp that you added was removed several years ago when this interchange was rebuilt. I am going to remove this ramp. |
86599717 | about 5 years ago | The section of US 35 that you tagged as motorway should really be tagged as trunk because it has at-grade intersections. Motorway=freeway in the US, (i.e. fully grade-separated and divided road) whereas the highway=trunk tag is typically used for divided highways with at-grade intersections. I've fixed this already, but please keep this in mind in the future. Thanks! |
86731746 | about 5 years ago | Again welcome! I'd like to add that none of the roads you tagged as primary should be primary. Only major roads (e.g. major state highways and US highways as well as major arterials) should be tagged as primary. Please change them back to how they were before. |
65057897 | about 5 years ago | Is this road still closed? |
85318677 | about 5 years ago | Still don't understand the inconsistency here. How about we just be more consistent and tag any road that's divided and has 2 consecutive interchanges (Lake Hefner Parkway has 7 1/2 from the northern end of the freeway and the I-44 interchange)? You know, like standard practice. :) |
85318677 | about 5 years ago | Also, why are you so bent out of shape over this freeway being tagged as motorway when US 77 just east of here is tagged as motorway even though the freeway section extending north of the Kilpatrick Turnpike is shorter than that of Lake Hefner Pkwy? |