Лагатып OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap

tourism:private=wilderness_hut

Апублікавана карыстальнікам einarr 5 Кастрычнік 2009 на мове English

I've tagged a few "wilderness_hut"s maintained by the local students' athletes association. Since these are not open to the general public (you need to be a member to use them), the "tourism" tag is not quite appropriate. Still, the tags commonly used together with the tourism tag fit well, so I've started putting tourism:private=wilderness_hut on them as a main tag. This maintains a relationship with the main tourism tag while preventing the huts to appear on tourist maps.

An alternative scheme would be to use tourism=wilderness_hut;access=private, but adding negative information in this way is generally frowned upon. It would require all users of the tourism tag to also check the private tag to find out whether the hut should be rendered.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Абмеркаванне

Каментар ад davespod у 5 Кастрычнік 2009 у 19:50

First time I've ever heard of tagging negatively being frowned upon, particularly access=private, which seems one of the less controversial tagging conventions.

Каментар ад IgnoredAmbience у 6 Кастрычнік 2009 у 12:51

Isn't this sort of tagging usually used for things that have closed, eg amenity=pub disused=yes is difficult.

access=private is a different matter imo.

Увайсці каб пакінуць каментар