OpenStreetMap-ан логотип OpenStreetMap

OSM is only as useful as the software that renders it

Арахецна escallic 27 April 2018, мотт: English

iD, JOSM, demo.f4map.com, osmbuildings.org - I’m calling out a few use cases for OSM today because I’d like to point out the difference in the quality of OSM data rendering.

Of course, OSM is more than just data: it’s a community! But it is also software. And that community must respond quickly to the demand for better quality maps (i.e. 3d, textured, or even animated). Every user uses OSM map data for different use cases.

iD is a great tool for mappers and is easily accessible through the web browser unlike JOSM, which also provides many other features (probably). Potlatch is a flash-based tool like iD that also allows dragging edges of nodes and viewing uploaded GPS traces. But neither tool will render the buildings or other topology.

This is where osmbuildings.org and especially demo.f4map.com become necessary tools to verify the 3D appearance of vector data when mapping. These tools possess the ability to modify our vector world from a perspective street view and bird’s eye view rather than solely from orthogonally projected satellite imagery.

Yet it is possible to adapt OSM to any structure on, in, or around earth in one continuum of data. It is possible to create orbital relations to other planets, each with its own spherical geographical coordinates to vector data. But the demand for OSM data awaits a community generous and flexible enough to provide the software that allows rendering and mapping it.

Email icon Bluesky Icon Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Mastodon Icon Telegram Icon X Icon

Дийцар

Коммент -karlos- 28 April 2018 07:32

I agree, the “OSM community” is focussing on collecting data and leafs the use of it to the commercial. F4 is commercial and even the Server of OSMBuildings is not open source. The commercial 3D renderers mostly are about data additional visualisation. F4, OSMBuildungs and OSM2WORLD try to show a realistic view, also the OSM Tags are not much intended for this. I started an experiment to show the OSM data tagging in 3D (www.OSMgo.org, www.twitter.com/OSM__go)

Some times I think iD happened because Flash is dying (and Java may follow) and because user from the USA don’t really like JOSM ;-) And non of the editors is WYSIWYG. Mainly because there is no commonly maintained open source vector renderer on the main page of OSM and no community vector server.

If it gets to software, there is no “OSM community” but personalities, seldom groups, coding news features. There is no “must” applayable. I dream of a client vector tile renderer with such flexible style file configurability, able to replace many other special OpenXxxMaps. Solved by existing code compiled to WebAssembly, running as Advanced Web App on mobile and desktop devices. It could be 2D and 3D and even editing WYSIWYG. Topology would be an additional callenge. If this shall become reality, OSM needs an agreement like it was with iD to head in this direction.

OSMgo

-karlos-

ЧугӀо, коммент йитарна