OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
153424572 about 1 year ago

Well that's a coincidence, the City of Kitchener actually finally got back to me, and state their license is compatible.

153424572 about 1 year ago

No worries, I think what's considered the Walter Bean trail is common enough local knowledge that it's not worth reverting.

Unfortunately, each city, the region, and the Grand River Conservation Authority all used their own independently modified version of the OGL (as in, it's not even just that they all decided to use one modified version of the actual OGL, they didn't even make the same changes to it). The changes are small enough that I suspect each license would be fine, but as a non-lawyer, I can't really judge, and the LWG doesn't want to go through each municipality in Canada that decided their lawyers in particular need to make some edits. I (and at least one other local) have tried reaching out to them multiple times over many years, and as recently as two weeks ago, but have never gotten an answer from any of them.

153424572 about 1 year ago

You can't use the region's data, they haven't provided a waiver and their license hasn't been approved. Can you list what in particular was sourced from that? Otherwise we'll have to revert the whole changeset.

153393384 about 1 year ago

resolves osm.org/note/4314686

152889949 about 1 year ago

The point is that you cannot copy data from other sources if you have not been given permission to do so. If you know a hotel exists because you personally have been there, or because you can see it from properly licensed imagery, or because it's in a properly licensed database, then you can add it, but if you are finding hotels by searching a website that did not give you permission to use the search results for OSM, that is not allowed (and makes mapping harder for everyone else).

See the wiki: osm.wiki/Copyright#Proprietary_data

Just as importantly, if the DWG reverts your edits, and you have not gotten permission from them to undo that revert, you cannot just decide they were wrong and do it anyway. That's a good way to get banned.

152908817 about 1 year ago

You detached the buildings, but left them overlapping. Do the buildings abut each other? Then they do indeed need to attach on the map. Do they have a gap between them? Then they need to be moved to show that.

152350563 about 1 year ago

This changeset broke the multipolygon for Victoria Park Lake. Please try to do fewer things in each changeset, it make it easier to notice these sorts of things.

152421193 about 1 year ago

You deleted the Breithaupt Park reserve. Was this an accident, or is there some sort of misunderstanding? Restored in osm.org/changeset/152427393

151638381 over 1 year ago

Thanks for the edits! Going forward, it's helpful if you provide a changeset summary, to help other editors in the area get a quick idea of what's going on.

151125976 over 1 year ago

Resloves osm.org/note/4238133

150984159 over 1 year ago

Resolves osm.org/note/4232763

150816153 over 1 year ago

nit: I should have cited Esri World Imagery for this edit as well (Bing doesn't have the newer inner buildings)

150420020 over 1 year ago

Resolves osm.org/note/4210564

150363780 over 1 year ago

You changed this stretch of the road from a residential road to a motorway (i.e., a freeway). I switched it back, but was this just a misclick, or was there something you were trying to change aside from the speed limit?

149714139 over 1 year ago

resolves osm.org/note/4187606

148772803 over 1 year ago

How were you able to tell the address is on Olympic and not Pattandon?

148323986 over 1 year ago

No worries, thanks for the edits!

141169353 over 1 year ago

Fair enough, I was probably looking in the wrong place. Thanks for the quick reply. :)

148323986 over 1 year ago

You tagged a width as "a", I'm guessing that's a typo:
osm.org/way/1117294685

148323078 over 1 year ago

It looks like you tagged a bunch of regular paths as crossings (cycleway=crossing). Crossings are for street crossings, not general paths. I went ahead and fixed it.