I was also wondering what data you based your change on?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73365588

You actually deleted a chunk of northbound Bangerter highway.. Please be careful when working on complex intersections especially when they involve major highways. I fixed the situation in osm.org/changeset/73387432. Let me know if you have any questions.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73365588

Hi Reemal,
This intersection was recently updated from an at-grade intersection to a freeway style intersection with on and off ramps. Was that what you were trying to represent here? Are you still working on this? Right now, it looks like you diverted the main southbound roadway to be the ramp. I will help complete this work based on recent OpenStreetCam images I took. Thanks for your work on the SLC area!
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73365588

If you're referring to osm.wiki/United_States_Roadway_Classification_Guidelines -- it's stated at the top of that page that this is not an official guideline. In fact, there is no clear consensus in the US OSM community about road classification, and lacking that, I would ask you to take a cautious approach and discuss these changes on the talk-us mailing list or on the OSM US Slack channel. Thanks!

Hi us89,
I'm noticing you're making some pretty impactful changes to road classification in Utah. I think this warrants some discussion. What documented OSM conventions are you following when making these changes? Are you looking at other states to inform your changes? Let's discuss.

Since this is the back access to the properties, highway=service is more appropriate here. Changed accordingly.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/73226397

Hi and welcome to OSM! Thanks for your contribution. If you plan on contributing more in the future, here's a few tips I hope you will find helpful:
1) Please draw the building outline to match as closely as possible with the available aerial imagery
2) use the correct format for opening hours as described in osm.wiki/Key:opening_hours -- this will help applications using OSM data to correctly parse the data and display accurate hours for the business.
Feel free to reach out with any questions and thanks for contributing again.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.mapbox.com/changesets/72886788

Hi Freedom Editor! Could you please add descriptive comments to your changesets? Especially when editing administrative relations and city nodes, it would help to know what triggered the change. Could you elaborate on this one specifically since I am local to Salt Lake City? Thanks!

Hi, welcome to OSM. It looks like you're trying to bulk-upload data into OSM using ArcGIS. The result of this upload is 2440 nodes (points) with no attributes. This is of no value to OSM. I am assuming you didn't mean to do harm and make a meaningful contribution to OSM. I am happy to help you with that, but I will revert (undo) this change. I am local (Salt Lake City) and run an OSM meetup which you are welcome to join!

Please message me through OSM (click on my username and click 'Send Message' if you want to work together on this. Looking forward to talking more!

[a link](https://example.com)


I posted to talk-us, please see https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-us/2019-May/019507.html

I looked again at the transit route wiki and it states the recommended value as "<type of transport><reference number>: <from> → <to> " which you also didn't follow. I am going to propose to discuss this on-list because I see you have been editing bus routes across the nation and others may be interested in weighing in.

Hi njtbusfan,
Thanks for helping work on the UTA transit relations. If you add new routes, please add them to osm.wiki/Utah/Transit#Utah_Transit_Authority_.28UTA.29 as well, and have a look at existing routes.

I see you changed the name tag on many UTA bus routes to something that is more descriptive but doesn't match the official routes names from UTA. Can I ask after your rationale please? Are you local to the area? I would appreciate it if you would discuss sweeping changes like this before implementing them.

Thanks,
mvexel

Thanks for your first OSM edit, CrowderSoup!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/

Thanks for your first OSM edit, CrowderSoup!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/

Thanks for your first OSM edit, CrowderSoup!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/

Thanks for your first OSM edit, CrowderSoup!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/

Thanks for your first OSM edit, CrowderSoup!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/

Thanks for your first OSM edit!
I run the OpenStreetMap Utah group, we have regular meetups in the SLC area. --> https://www.meetup.com/OpenStreetMap-Utah/