OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
23995102 about 2 months ago

There was a red naval mine on the harbourside - presumably deactivated.

165213227 4 months ago

Thanks for explaining your mapping style.

I added 3 items to the map to improve it -- whilst retaining the 1 item that was previously mapped.

There are others that are equally valid.

I map the area that each business occupies (or the best approximation).
This has a number of advantages:
- it's easier to update than POIs
- POIs are just some random location -- not even the centre of the item
- it's more difficult to delete a POI, since you can never really be sure that it's really gone, or did you just miss surveying it.
- There is an intrinsic relationship that can be used to determine the importance (based on area) that can be used by renderers.

In this specific case, I expect the building units to have different numbers (at least). You's issue that changing > 1 item is difficult can be solved -- at least in JOSM, you just hold shift when selecting to have multiple objects.

So, I hope you can see why items have been mapped in this changeset.

If you still consider that there is a problem, then there is a third potential mechanism which is to use "indoor mapping" to map each business as a notional room inside the building. It means that the building can be one area, while business are areas internally. I find rendering isn't so great -- but it does keep the advantages of area mapping, together with the ultra-pure-semantic approach of keeping the building as a single entity.

163794241 5 months ago

Reverting this - as it deletes useful housename information.

160523466 8 months ago

This should not be marked as private it is a public road.

156277976 12 months ago

OpenStreetMap is a volunteer-led project, so mapping is dependent on volunteers.

Thanks for adding your address.

I added the Cavell Road section recently -- walking it with a GPS to get the shape of the roads.

Unfortunately, the satellite maps that we are allowed to use aren't up to date yet -- and they are the easiest ways of tracing buildings.