OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
74860481 almost 6 years ago

Great - didn't see the restriction on the traffic light - just looked at the bollard :-)

74851721 almost 6 years ago

I will be changing some of your modifications, as I think your bus survey could have missed some details, e.g. there's a combined cycle and footway all the way along:

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=51.43762039018646&lng=-2.6231131596663397&z=17&pKey=2vpAWQV3Wadci-b3I3ciug&focus=map

74851721 almost 6 years ago

Looks like some typos in stop names?:
Ss Great Britain
Queen Square (Q1')

74851721 almost 6 years ago

How did you survey this?

I mapped the guided busway by walking it on foot and was extremely careful -- and I'm not sure about some of your changes.

I'll admit I probably used psv when I should have used bus.

74860481 almost 6 years ago

I can't see any no U-turn signs on Bing Streetside or Mapillary -- could you please post a link.

74801326 almost 6 years ago

Bus stops were originally imported from NAPTAN -- under OGL (see https://data.gov.uk/dataset/ff93ffc1-6656-47d8-9155-85ea0b8f2251/national-public-transport-access-nodes-naptan).

Ideally, you would be able to say the same licence (or something similar) applied to any information you are adding:names / locations / disuse, etc.

If you can't that's a problem. It could cause problems with other mappers and users of the data (commercial and otherwise) exposing them to the (potential) threat of litigation -- or at least having all your edits redacted osm.org/redactions/

If you'd followed the import guidelines -- then you'd have considered any licencing issues.

74826059 almost 6 years ago

Couldn't see steps tonight (it's boarded up) but shape seems close to map now.

Sometimes it's difficult to tell what's intentional when the river gets moved.

74801326 almost 6 years ago

I'll try and check the names tonight.

Regards copyright -- I'll flag it with the data working group -- they should have a better idea than me whether you are using a work derived from Ordnance Survey data.

74826059 almost 6 years ago

Cheers, that's a good first start.

Presume is still WIP given all the construction lines. Pretty sure "The Wellhead" was rectangular when I surveyed it -- looks a bit odd now.

74817920 almost 6 years ago

Presume you're reverting this too?
A lot of stuff seems to have been "sheared" -- https://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=74817920

74801326 almost 6 years ago

As for the particular issue of the bus stop names -- it's clear that the name is "The Centre" (https://www.flickr.com/photos/184597061@N05/48783615901/in/dateposted-public/ and https://www.flickr.com/photos/184597061@N05/48783611851/in/dateposted-public/)

74801326 almost 6 years ago

The PDF is "(c) Crown Copyright and database rights 2019, Ordnance Survey 100023406" -- if you're mapping/copying from that then that's going to be problematic.

I *really* don't want to upset you -- but you *do* need to check out the copyright situation -- OSM can't use anything from Ordnance Survey that isn't explicitly licenced. If it really is open data why isn't it on https://opendata.bristol.gov.uk/pages/homepage/

74801326 almost 6 years ago

The large bus stops are called "The Centre" -- there's little evidence for C1/C2. Might be on some digital display, but not on major infrastructure items -- there's a strong argument to revert this change to on the ground surveyed data.

Note: the C1/C2 were kept on the "official_name".

74750510 almost 6 years ago

I've removed the names that are housenumbers.

70617844 almost 6 years ago

The changeset was trying to correct the road geometries that had been dragged about badly.

Apologies if I upset something else.

74536525 almost 6 years ago

Looks like a ferry route got dragged north-east -- some strange artifacts on riverbanks near ferry terminals.

74528913 almost 6 years ago

Bristol Power Signal Box (and its chimney) used to match ESRI Clarity - not sure what it's matching now? Maybe stuff got dragged -- there's a wobble in the parking lane near Bristol Power Signal Box. GPS data isn't conclusive -- matched old version as well (if not better) than the new one?

74451791 almost 6 years ago

Can't see any no U-turn signs on Bing -- are you sure it's there?

74179599 almost 6 years ago

Moved to OSM message.

74179599 almost 6 years ago

Ok, it seems that you don't have a good idea of the licence or copyright of the data you are adding - and whether it's compatible with odbl, i.e. the openstreetmap licence. I wouldn't add any more until you can clarify things - it's probably something you should check.