I just updated my auto-generated page with lists: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/User:Yurik/OSM_wiki_tag_problems#List_pages -- these are only wikipedia articles with their wikidata's "instance of" = Q13406463 and Q15623926, but I could obviously add more. Let me know!

oops, wrong changeset, sorry.

I just updated my auto-generated page with lists: https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/User:Yurik/OSM_wiki_tag_problems#List_pages -- these are only wikipedia articles with their wikidata's "instance of" = Q13406463 and Q15623926, but I could obviously add more. Let me know

Alexey87, спасибо что посмотрели. Я прочитал на вики про islet (там несколько страниц в en & de), но там в основном обсуждается размер, а не то что это является ориентиром. Я в принципе не против, просто понять какие правила использовать для новичков. Пока что размер выглядит как единственное руководство к действию.

тут хорошие примеры:
osm.wiki/DE_talk:Tag:place%3Disland

Hi Jo, thanks for the comment! I am working on cleaning up all lists and disambiguation pages in wikipedia tags. For example, My scripts generate a list of all wikipedia tags that point to disambiguation https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/User:Yurik/OSM_disambigs list - we have already cleaned up almost 2000 incorrect ones.
Very soon will start fixing the lists as well, and there are thousands of those. I will work on creating a proposal for a guideline how to handle wikipedia lists and articles that contain information about the object, but are not dedicated to that object. Would you be interested in helping to create those guidelines? Thanks!

Hi @trigpoint, the Wikipedia title has a "normalized" form (actually the rules for it are very complex, such as each portion of the title has to be capital first, such as namespace, after namespace, and after each "/" if subpages are enabled). Plus some url decoding, spaces instead of underscores, and many other (Title parsing code is huge). While going to Wikipedia directly via the link would work ok, many other services would not be able to handle it - for example "en:pl:Foo" would not be matched in Wikidata. Keeping titles in a normal form would help many data consumers avoid (buggy) reimplementation of the title normalization.

Hi, i corrected some tags from this patch, especially n3276552767,n3276552770,n3276552771 -- but there is still a minor problem -- these are the only wikimedia_commons tags that use a search url instead of a proper Commons title like category:* or file:*. Could you change wikimedia_commons tag on these nodes to a category or an image? Or if they don't exist, lets delete those tags. Thanks!

heh, i'm not it for sure - i haven't written in it for 20+years :)

hi, you had invalid wikidata in way 197316406 - i changed it to fixme, please fix. thx!

hehe, i don't think there is anything "official" in OSM ever :) But yes, trying to normalize it a bit, hence asked :) Thanks for the reply!

Hi, do you mind if I convert media:commons -> wikimedia_commons? There are significantly more of those, and they are well documented in the wiki. Thx!

Hi, do you mind if I convert media:commons -> wikimedia_commons? There are significantly more of those, and they are well documented in the wiki. Thx!

Hi, I renamed landuse=residential,zopadpatti to landuse=residential;slum, hope its ok

Hi, what is "Vivasaya pannai" ? is it one of these, or something different? osm.wiki/Key:landuse
thanks!

oops, wrong description, simply added wd tag

Доброго времени, я добавлю wikidata таг для всех этих relations. Только не уверен - это admin boundaries или landuse?

Hi, thanks for adding "wikipedia" tags! I am adding corresponding 'wikidata' tags to all of them in Belarus now. Next time, please run "fetch wikidata" in JOSM (wikipedia plugin). Also, do you know if these should be landuse=residential, or if these are admin boundaries?

Hi, thanks for adding wikipedia tags to relations. Could you also do the "fetch wikidata" action on them in JOSM in the future? It will add wikidata tags. This action is part of the wikipedia plugin. Thank you!

Hi, thanks for fixing the wrong wp tag on relation 4016623. When you change wikipedia tags, could you run the "fetch wikidata" from JSOM? (its part of the wikipedia plugin). I will try to fix them, but sometimes i miss it, and besides, it is better to have just one edit :) Thanks!

Hi, thanks for adding wikipedia tag. When you add it, please use the "add field" instead of the "add tag" command in iD - this way it will automatically add corresponding wikidata tag as well. Thanks!