OpenStreetMap 로고 OpenStreetMap

Abandoned railway or gone forever?

pkoby님이 English로 2014년 2월 11일에 게시함.

At this location there is a line (that extends into Bellefonte) that marks an abandoned railway. This is only accurate in the sense that there was once a railway here, but there isn’t any trace of it other than the grade. Some of the grade has been appropriated into a cycle path. Some is now a road. But as far as I am aware, there is no point along this path where there is evidence of a railway.

As this feature cuts through various other (current) features, I think it should probably be removed and relegated to history. It’s essentially clutter at this point. If there were still tracks on the ground, then the tag would be appropriate, but it’s really just a path now (and not even half of it is that).

Thoughts?

위치: Greentree, State College, Centre County, Pennsylvania, 16804, United States
이메일 아이콘 Bluesky 아이콘 Facebook 아이콘 LinkedIn 아이콘 마스토돈 아이콘 텔레그램 아이콘 X 아이콘

토론

2014년 2월 11일 21:46lyx님의 의견

There has been a lot of discussion on this topic already. Please have a look at osm.wiki/Tag:railway%3Dabandoned and follow the links from there.

2014년 2월 11일 22:00zarl님의 의견

You already answered most of the questions yourself :-)

See railway=abandoned vs. demolished railway tracks: osm.wiki/Tag:railway%3Dabandoned osm.wiki/Demolished_Railway

Where it is used now as bicycle track just add highway=cycleway see also osm.wiki/Railways#Life-cycle

2014년 2월 12일 10:39Vincent de Phily님의 의견

For some reason, there seem to be a lot of overenthusiastic railway mappers who have a looser view of “it exists” than other mappers.

I try to be conservative and understanding when deleting stuff, but when I see tracks going thru buildings or swamps perfectly visible on Bing, it casts a shadow over the rest of the user’s contributions.

댓글을 남기려면 로그인하세요