OpenStreetMap
What happened to the city of Sacramento?
Käyttäjä rayKiddy kirjotti tämän 29. Septembera 2015 kielellä EnglishI have been fixing up boundaries of cities in California and I have found something odd.
Where is the city of Sacramento?
There is a city there, somewhere. There is a county. The county boundaries are at osm.org/relation/396460 and that all looks good. And it is not a county/city hybrid thing like San Francisco. Yes? And I can find the cities of West Sacramento, Rancho Cordova and others nearby, But I cannot find boundaries for the actual city of Sacramento. Google has boundaries for it, but OSM does not?
Or is there some way I should be finding it that I am not doing? I guess it could be mis-spelled.
I am going to the area around the county in http://overpass-turbo.eu/ and doing this search:
[out:json][timeout:360];
(
relation["name"="Sacramento"]({{bbox}});
way["name"="Sacramento"]({{bbox}});
node["name"="Sacramento"]({{bbox}});
);
out body;
>;
out skel qt;
It finds lot of stuff, but no city. Any ideas?
Discussion
Kommentti käyttäjältä ImreSamu 29. September 2015 klo 22.51
http://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=Sacramento#values
Kommentti käyttäjältä rayKiddy 29. September 2015 klo 23.50
Ah. I had forgotten about using that. And I still do not see a city.
Kommentti käyttäjältä Sanderd17 30. September 2015 klo 07.42
It looks like nobody ever created that boundary. No idea why.
Kommentti käyttäjältä Alan Trick 30. September 2015 klo 13.25
It seems to have been recreated: osm.org/changeset/34336415
Kommentti käyttäjältä rayKiddy 12. July 2018 klo 20.49
Well, that changeset does not re-create the relation. Interesting. It seems to me that one should be able to identify if the lines from the TIGER data are still there. I have not tried it, but it there should be something there.
And there is no changeset for the deletion? Perhaps that could be reversed….